The Welsh Government published a summary of responses to its consultation on proposals to strengthen the regulation and inspection of social care. The report said that there had been broad support for the proposals set out in the White Paper, alongside some requests for clarification and more details on certain elements, and a number of respondents identified that they would be keen to engage with Welsh Government in the further development of the proposals. It said that some areas of the consultation (such as negative registration and fees for registration of service providers) were unpopular with respondents.
Source: The Future of Regulation and Inspection of Care and Support in Wales: Consultation ï¿½ summary of responses, Welsh Government
A report examined the pilot in the south west of England of a new systems approach to case reviews and serious case reviews – Learning Together. The report outlined the methodology, discussed the learning gleaned to date from the pilot, and raised discussion points for policy.
Source: SCIE Learning Together: Reflections from the South West project, Social Care Institute for Excellence
A report examined progress on Making Safeguarding Personal, a social services led initiative in adult safeguarding. It said that councils reported seeing positive results from changes, but that the initial stages of the safeguarding process took time and had an impact on overall workload. The report identified some areas of practice that required further development, including: advocacy; practice and knowledge around the Mental Capacity Act and Deprivation of Liberty Safeguards; assessment and management of risk; recording systems; skills development; and leadership.
Source: Jane Lawson, Sue Lewis, and Cathie Williams, Making Safeguarding Personal 2013/14: Report of findings, Local Government Association
A study examined behavioural factors affecting social workers' decision-making in England, and how that might be improved, focused on the point at which children first came into contact with the child protection system. The report said that there were four key behavioural factors that affected social workers' decisions: time and workload pressures that increased the reliance upon intuition; a range of behavioural biases; decision fatigue; and the relatively low quality of available information. The report said that there was an overarching lack of robust evidence on what worked in particular contexts, which complicated all of these behavioural factors and compromised both existing diagnostic practice and the development of better approaches. The report concluded that future decision-making could be aided by insights from the behavioural sciences, and made a range of recommendations.
Source: Elspeth Kirkman and Karen Melrose, Clinical Judgement and Decision-Making in Children's Social Work: An analysis of the 'front door' system, Research Report 337, Department for Education
The inspectorate for healthcare and social care began consultation on proposals to change the way in which care services in England were regulated, inspected, and rated. Proposals included: the introduction of new methods of inspection, with Chief Inspectors and more specialist teams to include members of the public; a new system to help decide when, where and what to inspect; and listening to people's experiences of care. Future assessments would be based on five key questions, asking whether services were safe, effective, caring, responsive to people's needs, and well-led. The consultation would close on 4 June 2014.
Source: Care Quality Commission
The inspectorate for education and children's services examined the effectiveness of arrangements to safeguard children who experience neglect, drawing on case evidence and the views of parents, carers and professionals in England. It outlined areas of practice where there was particular concern, and said that more needed to be done to identify and respond effectively to the earliest stages of neglect. It called for local authorities and local safeguarding children boards to improve their understanding of the extent of neglect in their areas and to develop shared strategies to prioritize action. It also recommended that social work training should be improved, to increase professional understanding of the impact of neglect.
Source: In the Child's Time: Professional responses to neglect, HMI 140059, Office for Standards in Education, Children's Services and Skills
The government began consultation on proposals to impose a duty of candour on all providers registered with the Care Quality Commission. The duty would require organizations to be open with service users if they were harmed (above a certain 'harm threshold') as a result of their care or treatment. The document included draft regulations and asked about the anticipated impact on providers. The consultation would close on 25 April 2014.
Source: Introducing the Statutory Duty of Candour: A consultation on proposals to introduce a new CQC registration regulation, Department of Health
A report examined how social work service practitioners in Scotland might better understand the perspectives of people who might be at risk of harm, and considered ways to improve service user participation in investigations, decision-making and meetings. It said that service users and carers had mixed experiences, some good, but some adults felt more could have been done to help them understand what adult support and protection was about and to help them participate more. The project had examined and adapted existing tools, and developed new ones, for ongoing piloting.
Source: Bobby Brown, Jenny Bruce, Maureen Conway, Beth Cross, Neil Dunn, Fiona Gaffney, Michelle Howorth, Susan Hynd, Claire Lightowler, Kaye MacGregor, Kathryn Mackay, Senga McCulloch, Lee McLauchlan, Rhona Maxwell, Brian Rapley, Rose Sinclair, and Helen Winter, A Project to Support More Effective Involvement of Service Users in Adult Support and Protection Activity, Scottish Government
An article examined adult protection in Scotland, in particular how service users, family members, and service delivery professionals perceived the effectiveness of the protection orders issued under the Adult Support and Protection (Scotland) Act 2007. It said that, although there had been concerns about the potential for paternalistic practice and excessive use of orders, proportionality appeared to be applied in practice. It said that all parties were aware of the tensions between autonomy and protection, but there were beneficial outcomes from the careful use of orders.
Source: Michael Preston-Shoot and Sally Cornish, 'Paternalism or proportionality? Experiences and outcomes of the Adult Support and Protection (Scotland) Act 2007', Journal of Adult Protection, Volume 16 Number 1
A report examined the links between evidence and innovation in social work policy and practice in Scotland, exploring the associated conceptual, theoretical and empirical issues, and using case study examples.
Source: Jodie Pennacchia, Exploring the Relationships Between Evidence and Innovation in the Context of Scotlandï¿½s Social Services, Institute for Research and Innovation in Social Services
The government began consultation on proposals to change the system of regulation for health and social care organizations in England, including the introduction of legally mandated minimum standards, backed by enforcement options for the regulator. The consultation would close on 4 April 2014.
Source: Introducing Fundamental Standards: Consultation on proposals to change CQC registration regulations, Department of Health