Hostname: page-component-7c8c6479df-ph5wq Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-03-27T07:44:18.236Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Can artificial sweeteners help control body weight and prevent obesity?

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  14 December 2007

David Benton*
Affiliation:
Department of Psychology, University of Wales Swansea, Swansea, SA2 8PP, UK
*
Corresponding author: Dr David Benton, fax +44 1792 295 679, email d.benton@swansea.ac.uk
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Core share and HTML view are not available for this content. However, as you have access to this content, a full PDF is available via the ‘Save PDF’ action button.

The possible role played by artificial sweeteners in the long-term maintenance of body weight is considered. Although artificial sweeteners can play a role in a short-term energy-controlled diet, the evidence that they are helpful over a longer period is limited. In those in the recommended weight range there is evidence of compensation; that is, the consumption of low-energy foods is followed by an increased energy intake to make up the lost energy. Energy compensation is more likely in those not displaying dietary restraint. The desire to remove sugar from the diet reflects an assumption that its intake is associated with obesity. However, the consumption of energy-dense food, that almost entirely reflects a high fat and low water content, is the best predictor of obesity. Diets offering a high proportion of energy in the form of carbohydrate tend to contain low levels of fat. There are several reports that the use of artificial sweeteners leads to an increased consumption of fat. The weak ability of fat to satisfy hunger makes it easy to overeat fatty foods; in contrast, carbohydrates promote a feeling of ‘fullness’. Various short-term studies have found that carbohydrate consumed as a liquid, rather than a solid, is more likely to result in weight gain.

Type
Research Articles
Copyright
Copyright © The Author 2005

References

American Dietetic Association (2004) Position of the American Dietetic Association: use of nutritive and nonnutritive sweeteners. Journal of the American Dietetic Association 104, 255275.Google Scholar
Anderson, GH, Catherine, NLA, Woodend, DM & Wolever, TMS (2002) Inverse association between the effect of carbohydrates on blood glucose and subsequent short-term food intake in young men. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 76, 10231030.Google Scholar
Anderson, GH & Leiter, LA (1996) Sweeteners and food intake: relevance to obesity. Progress in Obesity Research 7, 345349.Google Scholar
Anderson, GH, Savaris, S, Schacher, S, Ziotkin, S & Leiter, LA (1989) Aspartame: effect on lunch-time food intake, appetite and hedonic response in children. Appetite 13, 93103.Google Scholar
Astrup, A & Raben, A (1995) Carbohydrate and obesity. International Journal of Obesity 19, Suppl. 5, S27–S37.Google Scholar
Beaton, GH, Tarasuk, V & Anderson, GH (1992) Estimation of possible impact of non-caloric fat and carbohydrate substitutes on macro-nutrient intake in the human. Appetite 19, 87103.Google Scholar
Bellisle, F, Altenburg de Assis, MA, Fieux, B, Preziosi, P, Galan, B, Guy-Grand, B & Herchberg, S (2001) Use of ‘light’ foods and drinks in French adults: biological, anthropometric and nutritional correlates. Journal of Human Nutrition and Dietetics 14, 191206.Google Scholar
Bellisle, F & Perez, C (1994) Low-energy substitutes for sugars and fats in the human diet: impact on nutritional regulation. Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews 18, 197205.Google Scholar
Benton, D (2002) Carbohydrate ingestion, blood glucose and mood. Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews 26, 293308.Google Scholar
Benton, D & Donohoe, RT (1999) The effects of nutrients on mood. Public Health Nutrition 2, 403409.Google Scholar
Berkey, CS, Rockett, HRH, Field, AE, Gillman, MW & Colditz, GA (2004) Sugar-added beverages and adolescent weight change. Obesity Research 12, 778788.Google Scholar
Birch, LL, McPhee, L & Sullivan, S (1989) Children's food intake following drinks sweetened with sucrose or aspartame: time course effects. Physiology and Behavior 45, 387395.Google Scholar
Blackburn, GL, Kanders, BS, Lavin, PT, Keller, PT & Whatley, J (1997) The effect of aspartame as part of a multi-disciplinary weight-control program on short- and long-term control of body weight. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 65, 409418.Google Scholar
Blundell, JE & Hill, AJ (1986) Paradoxical effects of an intense sweetener (aspartame) on appetite. Lancet i, 10921093.Google Scholar
Bolton-Smith, C & Woodward, M (1994) Dietary composition and fat to sugar ratios in relation to obesity. International Journal of Obesity and Related Metabolic Disorders 18, 820828.Google Scholar
Bouche, C, Rizkalla, SW, Luo, J, Vidal, H, Veronese, A, Pacher, N, Fouquet, C, Lang, V & Slama, G (2002) Five week low-glycemic index diet decreases total fat mass and improves plasma lipid profile in moderately overweight nondiabetic men. Diabetes Care 25, 822828.Google Scholar
Bray, GA, Nielsen, SJ & Popkin, BM (2004) Consumption of high-fructose corn syrup in beverages may play a role in the epidemic of obesity. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 79, 537543.Google Scholar
Campbell, RG, Hashim, SA & van Itallie, TB (1971) Studies of food-intake regulation in man: responses to variations in nutritive density in lean and obese subjects. New England Journal of Medicine 285, 14021407.Google Scholar
Chen, L-NA & Parham, ES (1991) College students' use of high-intensity sweeteners is not consistently associated with sugar consumption. Journal of the American Dietetic Association 91, 686690.Google Scholar
Colantuoni, C, Schwenker, J, McCarthy, J, Rada, P, Ladenheim, B, Cadet, JL, Schwartz, GJ, Moran, TH & Hoebel, BG (2001) Excessive sugar intake alters binding to dopamine and mu-opioid receptors in the brain. Neuroreport 16, 35493552.Google Scholar
de Castro, J (1993) The effect of the spontaneous ingestion of particular foods for beverages on the meal pattern and overall nutrient intake of humans. Physiology and Behavior 53, 11331144.Google Scholar
Dennison, BA, Rockwell, HL & Baker, SL (1997) Excess fruit juice consumption by preschool-aged children is associated with short stature and obesity. Pediatrics 99, 1522.Google Scholar
Drewnowski, A (1998) Energy density, palatability and satiety: implications for weight control. Nutrition Reviews 55, 3143.Google Scholar
Drewnowski, A (1999) Intense sweeteners and energy density of foods: implication for weight control. European Journal of Clinical Nutrition 53, 757763.Google Scholar
Drewnowski, A, Massien, C, Louis-Sylvestre, J, Fricker, J, Chapelot, D & Apfelbaum, M (1994) Comparing the effects of aspartame and sucrose on motivational ratings, taste preferences and energy intakes in humans. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 59, 338345.Google Scholar
Duncan, KH, Bacon, JA & Weinsier, RL (1983) The effects of high- and low-energy density diets on satiety, energy intake and eating time of obese and nonobese subjects. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 37, 763767.Google Scholar
Evans, E (1989) Effect of the withdrawal of artificial sweeteners on energy intake of stabilized post-obese women. International Journal of Obesity 13, Suppl. 1, 111.Google Scholar
Fernstrom, JD (1988) Carbohydrate ingestion and brain serotonin synthesis: relevance to a putative control loop for regulating carbohydrate ingestion, and effects of aspartame consumption. Appetite 11, Suppl. 1, 3541.Google Scholar
Fernstrom, JD, Fernstrom, MH & Grubb, PE (1986) Effects of aspartame ingestion on the carbohydrate-induced rise in tryptophan hydroxylase rate in rat brain. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 44, 97112.Google Scholar
Figlewicz, DP, Stein, LJ, West, D, Porte, D & Woods, SC (1986) Intracisternal insulin alters sensitivity to CCK-induced meal suppression in baboons. American Journal of Physiology 250, R856–R860.Google Scholar
Foltin, RW, Fischman, MW, Emurian, CS & Rachlinski, JJ (1988) Compensation for caloric dilution in humans given unrestricted access to food in a residential laboratory. Appetite 10, 1324.Google Scholar
Foltin, RW, Fischman, MW, Moran, TH, Rolls, BJ & Kelly, TH (1990) Caloric compensation for lunches varying in fat and carbohydrate content by humans in a residential laboratory. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 52, 969980.Google Scholar
Gatenby, SJ, Aaron, JI, Jack, VA & Mela, DJ (1997) Extended use of foods modified in fat and sugar content: nutritional implications in a free-living female population. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 65, 18671873.Google Scholar
Gerozissis, K (2004) Brain insulin and feeding: a bi-directional communication. European Journal of Pharmacology 490, 5970.Google Scholar
Gerozissis, K, Rouch, C, Lemierre, S, Nicolaidis, S & Orosco, M (2001) A potential role of central insulin in learning and memory related to feeding. Cellular and Molecular Neurobiology 21, 389401.Google Scholar
Gosnell, BA, Krahn, DD & Majchrzak, MJ (1990) The effects of morphine on diet selection are dependent upon baseline preferences. Pharmacology Biochemistry and Behavior 37, 207212.Google Scholar
Guthrie, JF & Morton, JF (2000) Food sources of added sweeteners in the diets of Americans. Journal of the American Dietetic Association 100, 4351.Google Scholar
Hall, WL, Millward, DJ, Rogers, PJ & Morgan, LM (2003) Physiological mechanisms mediating aspartame-induced satiety. Physiology and Behavior 78, 557562.Google Scholar
Havel, PJ (2001) Peripheral signals conveying metabolic information to the brain: short-term and long-term regulation of food intake and energy homeostasis. Experimental Biology and Medicine 226, 963977.Google Scholar
Havel, PJ, Townsend, R, Chaump, L & Teff, K (1999) High-fat meals reduce 24 h circulating leptin concentrations in women. Diabetes 48, 334341.Google Scholar
Hill, JO & Prentice, AM (1995) Sugar and body weight regulation. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 62, 264S–273S.Google Scholar
Holt, SHA, Brand Miller, JC, Petocz, P & Farmakalidis, E (1995) A satiety index of common foods. European Journal of Clinical Nutrition 49, 675690.Google Scholar
James, J, Thomas, P, Cavan, D & Kerr, D (2004) Preventing childhood obesity by reducing consumption of carbonated drinks: cluster randomised controlled trial. BMJ 328, 1237.Google Scholar
Kanders, BS, Lavin, PT, Kowalchuk, MB, Greenberg, I & Blackburn, GL (1988) An evaluation of the effect of aspartame on weight loss. Appetite 11, Suppl. 1, 7384.Google Scholar
Kanders, BS, Lavin, BT, Kowalchuk, M & Blackburn, GL (1990) Do aspartame (APM)-sweetened foods and beverages aid in long-term control of body weight. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 51, 515.Google Scholar
Kelley, AE, Bakshi, VP, Fleming, S & Holahan, MR (2000) A pharmacological analysis of the substrates underlying conditioned feeding induced by repeated opioid stimulation of the nucleus accumbens. Neuropharmacology 23, 455467.Google Scholar
Kelley, AE, Bakshi, VP, Haber, SN, Steininger, TL, Will, MJ & Zhang, M (2002) Opioid modulation of taste hedonics within the ventral striatum. Physiology and Behavior 76, 365377.Google Scholar
Krebs-Smith, SM (2001) Choose beverages and foods to moderate your intake of sugars: measurement requires quantification. Journal of Nutrition 131, 527S–535S.Google Scholar
Lavin, JH, French, SJ & Read, NW (1997) The effect of sucrose- and aspartame-sweetened drinks on energy intake, hunger and food choice of female moderately restrained eaters. International Journal of Obesity 21, 3742.Google Scholar
Leon, AS, Hunninghake, DB, Bell, C, Rassin, DK & Tephly, TR (1989) Safety of long-term large doses of aspartame. Archives of Internal Medicine 149, 23182324.Google Scholar
Lerer-Metzger, M, Rizkalla, SW, Luo, J, Champ, M, Kabir, M, Bruzzo, F, Barnet, F & Slama, G (1996) Effects of long-term low-glycaemic index starchy food on plasma glucose and lipid concentration and adipose tissue cellularity in normal and diabetic rats. British Journal of Nutrition 75, 723732.Google Scholar
Levine, AS, Kotz, CM & Gosnell, BA (2003) Sugars and fats: the neurobiology of preference. Journal of Nutrition 133, 835837.Google Scholar
Levy, AS & Heaton, AW (1993) Weight control practices of US adults trying to lose weight. Annals of Internal Medicine 119, 661666.Google Scholar
Louis-Sylvestre, J, Tornier, A, Verger, P, Chabert, M & Delorme, B (1989) Learned caloric adjustment of human intake. Appetite 12, 95103.Google Scholar
Ludwig, DS (2000) Dietary glycemic index and obesity. Journal of Nutrition 130, 280S–283S.Google Scholar
Ludwig, DS, Peterson, KE & Gortmaker, SL (2001) Relation between consumption of sugar-sweetened drinks and childhood obesity: a prospective observational analysis. Lancet 357, 505508.Google Scholar
Mattes, RD (1996) Dietary compensation by humans for supplemental energy provided as ethanol or carbohydrate in fluids. Physiology and Behavior 59, 179187.Google Scholar
Mela, DJ (1997) Fat and sugar substitutes: implications for dietary intakes and energy balance. Proceedings of the Nutrition Society 56, 827840.Google Scholar
Naismith, DJ & Rhodes, C (1995) Adjustment in energy intake following the covert removal of sugar from the diet. Journal of Human Nutrition and Dietetics 8, 167175.Google Scholar
Nicklas, TA, Yang, S-J, Baranowski, T, Zakeri, I & Berenson, G (2003) Eating patterns and obesity in children. The Bogalusa Heart Study. American Journal of Preventive Medicine 25, 916.Google Scholar
O'Brien Nabors, L (1999) Consumer perceptions of products containing sweeteners: USA. Low-calorie sweeteners: present and future. World Review of Nutrition and Dietetics 85, 140145.Google Scholar
Ott, DB, Edwards, CL & Palmer, SJ (1991) Perceived taste intensity and duration of nutritive and non-nutritive sweeteners using time-intensity evaluations. Journal of Food Sciences 56, 535542.Google Scholar
Pal, GK & Thombre, DP (1993) Modulation of feeding and drinking by dopamine in caudate and accumbens nuclei in rats. Indian Journal of Experimental Biology 31, 455467.Google Scholar
Parham, ES & Parham, AR (1980) Saccharin use and sugar intake by college students. Journal of the American Dietetic Association 76, 560563.Google Scholar
Pawlak, DB, Ebbeling, CB & Ludwig, DS (2002) Should obese patients be counseled to follow a low-glycaemic index diet? Yes. Obesity Review 3, 235243.Google Scholar
Pliner, P & Stallberg-White, C (2000) Pass the ketchup please; familiar flavours increase children's willingness to taste novel foods. Appetite 34, 95103.Google Scholar
Poppitt, SD & Prentice, AM (1996) Energy density and its role in the control of food intake: evidence from metabolic and community studies. Appetite 26, 153174.Google Scholar
Porikos, KP, Booth, G, van Itallie, TB (1977) Effect of covert nutritive dilution on the spontaneous food intake of obese individuals: a pilot study. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 30, 16381644.Google Scholar
Porikos, KP, Hesser, MF, van Itallie, TB (1982) Caloric regulation in normal weight men maintained on a palatable diet of conventional foods. Physiology and Behavior 29, 293300.Google Scholar
Raben, A (2002) Should obese patients be counseled to follow a low-glycaemic index diet? No. Obesity Reviews 3, 245256.Google Scholar
Raben, A, Vasilaras, TH, Moller, AC & Astrup, A (2002) Sucrose compared with artificial sweeteners: different effects on ad libitum food intake and body weight after 10 weeks of supplementation in overweight subjects. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 76, 721729.Google Scholar
Reid, M & Hammersley, R (1998) The effect of blind substitution of aspartame-sweetened for sugar-sweetened soft drinks on appetite and mood. British Food Journal 100, 254259.Google Scholar
Renwick, AG (1993) Intense sweeteners, food intake and the weight of a body of evidence. Physiology and Behavior 55, 139143.Google Scholar
Rodin, J (1990) Comparative effects of fructose, aspartame, glucose and water preloads on calorie and macro-nutrient intake. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 51, 428435.Google Scholar
Rogers, PJ, Burley, VJ, Alikhanizadeh, LA & Blundell, JE (1995) Postingestive inhibition of food intake by aspartame: importance of interval between aspartame administration and subsequent eating. Physiology and Behavior 57, 489493.Google Scholar
Rogers, PJ, Carlyle, J, Hill, AJ & Blundell, JE (1988) Uncoupling sweet taste and calories: comparison of the effects of glucose and three intense sweeteners on hunger and food intake. Physiology and Behavior 43, 547552.Google Scholar
Rogers, PJ, Pleming, HC & Blundell, JE (1990) Aspartame ingested without tasting inhibits hunger and food intake. Physiology and Behavior 47, 12391243.Google Scholar
Rolls, BJ, Bell, EA & Thorwart, ML (1999) Water incorporated into a food but not served with a food decreases energy intake in lean women. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 70, 448455.Google Scholar
Rolls, BJ, Castellanos, VH, Halford, JC, Kilara, A, Panyam, D, Pelkman, CL, Smith, GP & Thorwart, ML (1998) Volume of food consumed affects satiety in men. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 67, 11701177.Google Scholar
Rolls, BJ, Fedoroff, IC, Guthrie, JF & Laster, LJ (1990) Foods with different satiating effects in humans. Appetite 15, 115126.Google Scholar
Rolls, BJ, Kim-Harris, S, Fischman, MW, Moran, TH & Stoner, SA (1994) Satiety after preloads with different amounts of fat and carbohydrate: implications for obesity. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 60, 476487.Google Scholar
Saris, WHM, Astrup, A, Prentice, AM, Zunft, HJ, Formiguera, X, Verboeket-van de Venne, WP, Raben, A, Poppitt, SD, Seppelt, B, Johnston, S, Vasilaras, TH & Keogh, GF (2000) Randomized controlled trial of changes in dietary carbohydrate/fat ratio and simple vs complex carbohydrates on body weight and blood lipids. International Journal of Obesity and Related Metabolic Disorders 24, 13101318.Google Scholar
Schwartz, MW, Boyko, EJ, Kahn, SE, Ravussin, E & Bogardus, C (1995) Reduced insulin secretion: an independent predictor of body weight gain. Journal of Clinical Endocrinology and Metabolism 80, 15711576.Google Scholar
Slabber, M, Barnard, HC, Kuyl, JM, Dannhauser, A & Schall, R (1994) Effects of a low-insulin-response, energy-restricted diet on weight loss and plasma insulin concentrations in hyperinsulinemic obese females. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 60, 4853.Google Scholar
Spiegel, TA (1973) Caloric regulation of food intake in man. Journal of Comparative and Physiological Psychology 84, 2437.Google Scholar
Stellman, SD & Garfinkel, L (1986) Artificial sweetener use and one-year weight change among women. Preventive Medicine 15, 195202.Google Scholar
Stubbs, RJ, Harbron, CG & Prentice, AM (1996) Covert manipulation of the dietary fat to carbohydrate ratio of isoenergetically dense diets: effects on food intake in feeding men ad libitum. International Journal of Obesity 20, 651660.Google Scholar
Stubbs, RJ, Murgatroyd, PR, Goldberg, GR & Prentice, AM (1993) Carbohydrate balance and the regulation of day-to-day food intake in humans. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 57, 897903.Google Scholar
Teff, KL, Young, SN, Marchand, L & Botez, MI (1989) Acute effect of protein or carbohydrate breakfasts on human cerebrospinal fluid monoamine precursor and metabolite levels. Journal of Neurochemistry 52, 235241.Google Scholar
Tordoff, MG (1988) Sweeteners and appetite. In Sweeteners: Health Effects, pp. 5360 [Williams, GM, editor]. Princeton, NJ: Princeton Scientific.Google Scholar
Tordoff, MG & Alleva, AM (1990) Effect of drinking soda sweetened with aspartame or high-fructose corn syrup on food intake and body weight. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 51, 963969.Google Scholar
Tordoff, MG & Friedman, MI (1989) Drinking saccharin increases food intake and preference: I. Comparison with other drinks. Appetite 12, 110.Google Scholar
Troiana, RP, Briefel, RR, Marroll, MD & Bialostosky, K (2000) Energy and fat intakes of children and adolescents in the United States: data from the National Health and Nutrition Examination Surveys. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 72, 1343S–1353S.Google Scholar
Tuorila, H, Pangborn, RM & Schutz, HG (1990) Choosing a beverage: comparison of preferences and beliefs related to the reported consumption of regular vs diet soda. Appetite 14, 18.Google Scholar
van Stratum, P, Lussenburg, RN, van Wezel, LA, Vergroesen, AJ & Cremer, HD (1978) The effect of dietary carbohydrate:fat ratio on energy intake by adult women. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 31, 206212.Google Scholar
Vermut, SHF, Pasman, WJ, Schaafsma, G & Kardinaal, FM (2003) Effects of sugar intake on body weight: a review. Obesity Reviews 4, 9199.Google Scholar
Vickers, SP & Dourish, CT (2004) Serotonin receptor ligands and the treatment of obesity. Current Opinion in Investigational Drugs 5, 377388.Google Scholar
Woods, SC, Decke, E & Vasselli, JR (1974) Metabolic hormones and regulation of body weight. Psychological Review 81, 2643.Google Scholar
Wooley, OW (1971) Long-term food regulation in the obese and nonobese. Psychosomatic Medicine 33, 436444.Google Scholar
World Health Organization (2003) Diet, Nutrition and the Prevention of Chronic Diseases. WHO Technical Report no. 916. Report of Joint WHO/FAO Expert Consultation. Geneva: WHO.Google Scholar
Wurtman, RJ, Hefti, F & Melamed, E (1981) Precursor control of neurotransmitter synthesis. Pharmacological Review 32, 315335.Google Scholar
Yeomans, MR, Wright, P, Macleod, HA & Critchley, JA (1990) Effects of nalmefene on feeding in humans. Dissociation of hunger and palatability. Psychopharmacology 100, 426432.Google Scholar
Zhang, M, Gosnell, BA & Kelley, AE (1998) Intake of high-fat food is selectively enhanced by mu opioid receptor stimulation within the nucleus accumbens. Journal of Pharmacology and Expermental Therapeutics 285, 908914.Google Scholar
Zhang, M & Kelley, AE (1997) Opiate agonists microinjected into the nucleus accumbens enhance sucrose drinking in rats. Psychopharmacology 132, 350360.Google Scholar
Zhang, M & Kelley, AE (2002) Intake of saccharin, salt, and ethanol solutions is increased by infusion of a mu opioid agonist into the nucleus accumbens. Psychopharmacology 159, 415423.Google Scholar