Hostname: page-component-8448b6f56d-dnltx Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-23T07:35:12.627Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

European Traders and the Mpondo Paramountcy, 1878–1886

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  22 January 2009

William Beinart
William Beinart
Affiliation:
Queen Elizabeth House, Oxford
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

For a brief period between about 1878 and 1886, European traders in Eastern Pondoland played an important role in the politics of the chieftaincy. In these years the formerly amicable relationship between the Mpondo chiefs and the Cape Colony broke down. An expansionist colonial government confiscated the Mpondo port at St Johns, took control of an area claimed by the paramountcy, and threatened the political independence of the chiefs. The traders, especially a few larger wholesale firms, allied themselves with the paramount in his struggle to regain his land and port. Some traders feared that colonial encroachments would affect the concessions they had obtained from the paramount and that customs duties charged by the Cape at Port St Johns would undermine their competitiveness. Others, faced with an acute trading depression in 1882–3, sought to increase their share of the Pondoland market and hoped that conflict between the Cape and the Mpondo would stimulate a new boom. The chiefs, on their side, were receptive to the political overtures of the traders. As traders penetrated the area, they began to lose control over production and became increasingly dependent on taxing trade and granting concessions. They had lost confidence in missionary scribes and looked to the traders to provide secretarial skills. Various groups of traders could also give aid in the prosecution of Mpondo diplomacy by supplying firearms, opening negotiations with the imperial authorities, and establishing a new port. The alliance was formed at a specific moment in the penetration of merchant capital into an independent African polity. It serves to illustrate that some traders were prepared to act independently of the colonial powers in order to protect their interests.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Journal of African History , Volume 20 , Issue 4 , October 1979 , pp. 471 - 486
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1979

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Cragg, D. G. L., ‘The Relations of the Amampondo and the Colonial Authorities (1830–1886) with special reference to the role of the Wesleyan Missionaries’ (D.Phil, thesis, Oxford, 1959)Google Scholar. See also, for example, Thompson, L. M., Survival in Two Worlds (London, 1975)Google Scholar; Etherington, N., Preachers, Peasants and Politics in Southeast Africa, 1835–1880 (London, 1978).Google Scholar

2 Aborigines Protection Society papers (APS) G. 10, Chesson, to Derby, , 26 April 1884.Google Scholar

3 APS C149/106, Mqikela, to High Commissioner, 12 July 1884.Google Scholar

4 Cragg, , ‘Amampondo’, ch. 13.Google Scholar

5 Ibid.

6 A notable exception is the work of Neil Parsons on the Tswana. See Parsons, N., ‘The Economic History of Khama's Country in Botswana, 1844–1930’, in Palmer, R. and Parsons, N. (eds.), The Roots of Rural Poverty in Central and Southern Africa (London, 1977).Google Scholar

7 See Bundy, Colin, ‘African Peasants and Economic Change in South Africa, 1870–1913, with particular reference to the Cape’ (D.Phil, thesis, Oxford, 1976).Google Scholar

8 For a fuller treatment of economic change in nineteenth-century Pondoland see W. Beinart, ‘Production and the material basis of chieftainship: Pondoland, 1830–1880’, to be published in S. Marks and A. Atmore (eds.), Economy and Society in Pre-industrial Southern Africa.

9 Wesleyan Methodist Missionary Society (WMMS), papers, Jenkins, passim (Killie Campbell Africana Library, Durban: MSS. 1557, 1581).Google Scholar

10 Public Record Office, London: CO 48/408, report by Currie, , 29 June 1861.Google Scholar

11 Information on the Bouveries is drawn largely from the O'Donnell papers in the Cape Archives, Accession 1403 (CA O'D). These consist of about fifty sorted letter books, account books and diaries and a variety of unsorted ledgers and daily balance books covering the period 1882–1914. Mr B. Gallagher of Durban has in his possession some correspondence and documents relating to the same trading firm.

12 CA O'D 27, passim.

13 CA O'D 27, letter dated 12 April 1882.

14 CA O'D, 1–8 and 29. Calculated from diaries and letter books.

15 Cragg, , ‘Amampondo’, ch. 5.Google Scholar

16 CO 48/485, Blyth, to Littleton, , 10 Dec. 1877Google Scholar, in Frere, to Beach, Hicks, 22 May 1878Google Scholar. Some sources suggest that the sum collected was, or had been increased to, £20. See Cape of Hope, Good, Return of Papers on Pondo Affairs, A. 105–1880, 72Google Scholar; British Parliamentary Papers (P.P.), Correspondence Respecting the Affairs of Pondoland, C.5022 (1888), 68.Google Scholar

17 Cape, , Papers on Pondo Affairs, 38Google Scholar; P.P., C.5022, 22; Cape, , Blue Book on Native Affairs (BBNA), G. 13 (1880), 164.Google Scholar

18 Cape, , BBNA, G.13 (1880), 164.Google Scholar

19 Cape, , Papers on Pondo Affairs, 38, 173.Google Scholar

20 Kaffrarian Watchman, 7 Nov. 1877.Google Scholar

21 Cragg, , ‘Amampondo’, chs. 11Google Scholar and 12.

22 Cape, , Papers on Pondo Affairs, 36–8.Google Scholar

23 Hattersley, A., Later Annals of Natal (London, 1938), 23 fl.Google Scholar

24 Cape, , Papers on Pondo Affairs, 28Google Scholar, 31, 48.

25 Calculated from figures in Cape, BBNA, G.33 (1882).Google Scholar

26 Cape, , Papers on Pondo Affairs, 48Google Scholar; Tredgold, and Buchanan, , Decisions of the Supreme Court, Cape of Good Hope, xii (1895)Google Scholar, Cook Bros vs. the Colonial Government.

27 Brownlee, C. P., Reminiscences of Kafir Life and History (Lovedale, 1916), 119.Google Scholar

28 Cape, , Papers on Pondo Affairs, 63, 64.Google Scholar

29 CO 48/485, Blyth, to Littleton, , 10 Dec. 1877Google Scholar, in Frere, to Beach, Hicks, 22 May 1878Google Scholar; Kokstad Advertiser, 12 July 1884.

30 See Cragg, , ‘Amampondo’, passimGoogle Scholar; WMMS, Pilcher, J. to Secretaries, 27 Aug. 1862Google Scholar; MacQuarrie, J. W., Reminiscences of Sir Walter Stanford, ii (Cape Town, 1962), 42.Google Scholar

31 Cape, , BBNA, G.33 (1882), 69.Google Scholar

32 Kokstad Advertiser, 5 May 1883.

33 For details about Welborne and his career see especially Kokstad Advertiser, November and December 1885.Google Scholar

34 Kokstad Advertiser, 26 Dec. 1885. Boshoff had been in Pondoland since the early 1870s. See Natal Archives, Shepstone, H. C., ‘Diary’, Vol. 2, 28 11. 1872.Google Scholar

35 Ibid.

36 Cape, , Papers on Pondo Affairs, 48Google Scholar; and Elliot, and Blyth, to Secretary of Native Affairs, 7 May 1878.Google Scholar

37 Kokstad Advertiser, November and December 1883 and 26 Dec. 1885.

38 Information on MacNicholas from Gallagher papers, 1882 and 1883; Archives, Cape, Native Affairs papers (CA NA), Oxland to SNA, 16 Nov. 1883Google Scholar; APS C149/106, Mqikela to High Commissioner, 12 July 1884.

39 CA O'D 27, Bouverie, J. P. to MacNicholas, , 11 May 1882Google Scholar and passim.

40 papers, Gallagher, 1882Google Scholar and 1883.

41 Kokstad Advertiser, 21 Nov. 1885.Google Scholar

42 Kokstad Advertiser, November and December 1885.

43 CA O'D 27, passim.

44 Ibid. There is considerable discussion of the local slump in trade in the Kokstad Advertiser during late 1882 and 1883. See also Colony of Natal, Report of the Trade Commission, 1886 (Pietermaritzburg, 1887).

45 CA O'D 27, Bouverie, to Adler, , 13 March 1882Google Scholar, Jenkins, and Bouverie, to Gladstone, , 15 March 1882Google Scholar and following correspondence.

46 CA O'D 27, Bouverie, W. P. to Gladstone, , 28 Aug. 1882.Google Scholar

47 See especially the Kokstad Advertiser, 1882 and 1883, and Cape, , Blue Books on Native Affairs (1882) 69Google Scholar, and Ibid. (1883), 226.

48 Information on O'Donnell from interview with B. Gallagher, Durban; District Record Book, Flagstaff, 141; O'Donnell papers and Gallagher collection.

49 Kokstad Advertiser, 18 Aug. 1883. There are newspaper cuttings of the trial, which received considerable publicity, and details of O'Donnell's legal expenses in the papers, Gallagher, 1883.Google Scholar

50 CA NA 163, Oxland, to SNA, 30 Oct. 1883.Google Scholar

51 papers, Gallagher, 1884Google Scholar and 1885.

52 Kokstad Advertiser, 3 Nov. 1883 and 10 Nov. 1883.

53 CA NA 163, Bros, Anderton, to Oxland, , 15 Nov. 1883Google Scholar in Oxland, to SNA, 22 Nov. 1883.Google Scholar

54 Davenport, T. R. H., The Afrikaner Bond (Cape Town, 1966)Google Scholar; Cragg, , ‘Amampondo’, chs. 12 and 13Google Scholar; Kokstad Advertiser, 1883. P.P., Correspondence respecting the Affairs of Pondoland, C. 4590.

55 Kokstad Advertiser, 5 May 1883. The newspaper was used by Mhlangaso as a medium in which to publish his proclamations, and it carried regular reports from correspondents in Pondoland, including MacNicholas.

56 APS C149/106, Mqikela to High Commissioner, 12 July 1884. For a colonial view of Mpondo strategy see CA NA 162, Oxland, to SNA, 15 May 1883.Google Scholar

57 See correspondence in APS papers, especially C149/103–106a.

58 APS C126/66–68.

59 P.P., C. 4590.

60 APS C141/304, 305, 305a; Kokstad Advertiser, 18 Oct. 1884.

61 Information on Turner is from a typescript collection of his letters in the possession of Mrs S. Taylor, Port St Johns. A letter from Turner to Hitchin, C., Natal merchant and legislative councillor (18 Feb. 1894)Google Scholar in Mrs Taylor's scrapbook contains valuable information about his negotiations with the paramount over the port. Some of the Turner letters are on microfilm at Jagger Library, University of Cape Town.

62 P.P., C. 4590, Oxland, to SNA, 29 March 1884Google Scholar in Robinson to Derby, 29 April 1884 and passim.

63 Ibid.

64 MacQuarrie, , Stanford, 11Google Scholar, 2fl.

65 Kokstad Advertiser, 4, 11 and 18 July 1885.

66 papers, Turner; Kokstad Advertiser, 11 July 1885Google Scholar and 17 Dec. 1885. Holt, B., They Came Our Way (London, 1974), 139Google Scholar; P.P., C. 5022, 37; P.P., C. 4590, Whindus to Under SNA, 13 April 1885.

67 MacQuarrie, , Stanford, 11Google Scholar, 43; P.P., Correspondence respecting the Affairs of Pondoland, C. 5410, Memorandum, , 21 Sept. 1887Google Scholar. by de Smidt, P. J. in Sprigg to Governor, 7 Oct. 1887.Google Scholar

68 MacQuarrie, , Stanford, 11, 48Google Scholar; P.P., C. 5022, 67fl.

69 For agitation and opinion in East Griqualand, see Kokstad Advertiser, July 1885 to January 1886.

70 papers, Turner; Kokstad Advertiser, 4 April 1885.Google Scholar

71 Kokstad Advertiser, 26 Dec. 1885Google Scholar and following months; MacQuarrie, , Stanford, 11, 47fl. and chapter xxx.Google Scholar

72 Cragg, , ‘Amampondo’, chapters 13 and 14Google Scholar; MacQuarrie, , Stanford, 11, 45Google Scholar; Rock, H., ‘Reminiscences’ MS. 15, 799Google Scholar in Cory Library, Grahamstown; the Stanford Papers, series Ca (University of Cape Town) contain Hargreaves’ correspondence with Stanford, Chief Magistrate of East Griqualand at the time.

73 Kokstad Advertiser, August and September 1886.Google Scholar

74 Cape, of Good Hope, Memorandum on the Pondo Settlement of December 1886 and the Events which led to it, G.10 (1887).Google Scholar

75 CA O'D 29, O'Donnell to Resident Magistrate, Alfred, 11 March 1889 and following correspondence; Bouverie, J. P. to Scott, , 22 Jan. 1890Google Scholar and following correspondence; Kokstad Advertiser, 25 April 1894.Google Scholar

76 CA O'D 8, entry on 29 March 1894.

77 CA O'D 8, entry on 21 Aug. 1894.