Oryx

Forum

Conservation, evidence and policy

William. M. Adamsa1 and Chris Sandbrooka2 c1 *

a1 Department of Geography, University of Cambridge, Cambridge, UK

a2 UNEP World Conservation Monitoring Centre, Cambridge, CB3 0DL, UK

Abstract

A growing literature argues for evidence-based conservation. This concept reflects a wider approach to policy-making and follows thinking in medicine, in which rigorous, objective analysis of evidence has contributed to widespread improvements in medical outcomes. Clearly, conservation decisions should be informed by the best information available. However, we identify issues relating to the type and sources of evidence commonly used and the way evidence-based conservation studies frame policy debate. In this paper we discuss two issues; firstly, we ask ‘what counts as evidence?’ (what is meant by evidence, and what kind of evidence is given credibility). We conclude that evidence-based conservation should adopt a broad definition of evidence to give meaningful space for qualitative data, and local and indigenous knowledge. Secondly, we ask ‘how does evidence count?’ (the relationship between evidence and the policy-making process). We conclude that there should be greater recognition that policy-making is a complex and messy process, and that the role of evidence in policy making can never be neutral. In the light of these issues we suggest some changes to build on developing practice under the title evidence-informed conservation. The change in terminology is subtle, yet it has profound implications in that it calls for a re-positioning and re-understanding of conservation science as one source of information among many for decision-makers.

(Received July 01 2012)

(Revised October 17 2012)

(Accepted October 19 2012)

(Online publication May 10 2013)

Keywords

  • Conservation;
  • evidence-based conservation;
  • knowledge;
  • policy;
  • science–policy interface

Correspondence

c1 (Corresponding author) E-mail chris.sandbrook@unep-wcmc.org

Footnotes

*  Also at: Department of Geography, University of Cambridge, Cambridge, UK

Metrics
0Comments
Related Content