British Journal of Nutrition

Review article

The validity of self-reported energy intake as determined using the doubly labelled water technique

R. J. Hilla1* and P. S. W. Daviesa1 c1*

a1 School of Human Movement Studies, Faculty of Health, Queensland University of Technology, Brisbane, Queensland, Australia

Abstract

In the 1980s the development of the doubly labelled water (DLW) technique made it possible to determine the validity of dietary assessment methods using external, independent markers of intake in free-living populations. Since then, the accuracy of self-reported energy intake (EI) has been questioned on a number of occasions as under-reporting has been found to be prevalent in many different populations. This paper is a review of investigations using the DLW technique in conjunction with self-reported EI measures in groups including adults, children and adolescents, obese persons, athletes, military personnel and trekking explorers. In studies where a person other than the subject is responsible for recording dietary intake, such as parents of young children, EI generally corresponds to DLW determined energy expenditure. However, in instances where the subjects themselves report their intake, EI is generally under-reported when compared with energy expenditure. It was originally believed that this phenomenon of under-reporting was linked to increased adiposity and body size, however, it is now apparent that other factors, such as dietary restraint and socio-economic status, are also involved. This paper therefore aims to present a more comprehensive picture of under-reporting by tying in the findings of many DLW studies with other studies focusing particularly on the characteristics and mechanisms for under-reporting. Awareness of these characteristics and mechanisms will enable researchers to obtain more accurate self-reports of EI using all dietary recording techniques.

(Received December 07 1999)

(Revised October 20 2000)

(Accepted October 20 2000)

Correspondence:

c1 Corresponding author: Dr P. S. W. Davies, fax +61 7 3636 1981, email ps.davies@mailbox.uq.edu.au

Footnotes

* Children's Nutrition Research Centre, Department of Paediatrics and Child Health, Royal Children's Hospital, Herston, Brisbane, Queensland 4029, Australia.

0Comments