The Journal of Ecclesiastical History

Research Article

Dominican-Jesuit Rivalry and the Politics of Catholic Renewal in Poland 1564–1648


a1 22 Hereford Road, Acton, London W3 9JW; e-mail:


Highlighting some of the tensions within Catholicism in Poland-Lithuania after the Council of Trent, this article offers a corrective to the traditional Jesuit-centred paradigm of Catholic renewal. While long held to be central to the successes of the Counter-Reformation, the Jesuits were opposed by large sections of the Catholic nobility, a paradox that has never been adequately explained. By exploring the conflicts between the Jesuits and the more established Dominican order, the phenomenon of Catholic anticlericalism can be understood as part of a wider dissonance in Catholic culture, and integral to the accommodation of noble and Catholic culture after Trent.

(Online publication March 04 2011)