Journal of Tropical Ecology

The effects of forest type, harvesting and stand refinement on early seedling recruitment in a tropical rain forest

a1 Muséum National d'Histoire Naturelle, Laboratoire d'Ecologie Générale, UMR 8571 CNRS-MNHN, 4 avenue du Petit Château, F-91800 Brunoy, France
a2 INRA, Campus Agronomique de Kourou, BP 709, 97387 Kourou cedex, Guyane française
a3 SILVOLAB, ENGREF Centre de Kourou, BP 316, 97379 Kourou cedex, Guyane Francaise


Maintenance of high plant diversity in tropical rain forests has been hypothesized to be related to intense seed predation, and studies have shown that the impact of seed-eaters varies according to seed size, forest type and level of disturbance. The hypothesis that seed survival and seedling recruitment depending on seed size, are related to forest type and the intensity of harvesting and stand refinement was therefore tested at Paracou, French Guiana, for three animal-dispersed tree species. Two forest areas, corresponding to two forest types, were selected based on the occurrence of a dominant species, Eperua falcata (Caesalpiniaceae). Two factors were tested: forest type (E. falcata-rich and E. falcata-poor) and level of harvesting (unlogged, low intensity of logging, low intensity of logging and thinning liberation by tree-poison girdling) within each forest type. Overall, there was no effect of species nor of logging treatment within forest type after 6 wk. There was only a significant effect of forest type on seed survival in the large-seeded Carapa procera, a rodent-dispersed species in the Meliaceae. In the two medium-sized seed species, Pradosia cochlearia and Manilkara bidentata, two frugivore-dispersed Sapotaceae, the effect of treatment was overall significant but was also highly variable between plots within treatments. After 1 y, C. procera showed little seedling recruitment due to low seed removal and dispersal, and high seed-seedling predation under all conditions. Neither forest type, nor treatment nested within forest type, affected seedling recruitment in P. cochlearia whereas M. bidentata seedlings were favoured in unlogged conditions at the E. falcata-poor forest type. These results suggest that species characteristics (such as seed size and palatability), or local tree diversity and resources for granivores select for contrasting patterns in tree recruitment between forest type in the rodent-dispersed tree species, and these interact with level of tree harvesting and stand refinement in the other frugivore-dispersed tree species.

(Accepted January 11 2001)

Key Words: Carapa procera; Eperua falcata; Manilkara bidentata; Paracou; Pradosia cochlearia; seed; seedling; selective logging.

c1 Corresponding author. Email: