Hostname: page-component-8448b6f56d-jr42d Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-18T03:53:52.643Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Why Can't Private Art “Trophies” Go Home from the War?

The Baldin-Bremen Kunsthalle Case: A Cause-Célèbre of German-Russian Restitution Politics

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  17 September 2010

Konstantin Akinsha
Konstantin Akinsha
Affiliation:
ARTnews. Email: akinsha@fastmail.net
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This article is dedicated to the collection from the Bremen Kunsthalle, comprising 1715 drawings, 50 paintings, and about 3000 prints found by Soviet troops in castle of Karnzow near Berlin in May 1945. The collection was not seized by Soviet trophy brigades but was looted by soldiers and officers of the 38th Field Engineers' Brigade of the Red Army.

After their return to the USSR and demobilization, some of the officers donated their loot to different museums around the Soviet Union. One of the most important parts of the collection, with 362 drawings and two paintings—among them works of Dürer, Rembrandt, Goya, and Van Gogh, was appropriated by Captain Viktor Baldin. In 1948 Baldin deposited his loot in the A. V. Shchusev State Research Museum of Architecture in Moscow. Later Baldin became the director of the museum and advocated return of the art to its rightful owners.

Since the days of Gorbachev's perestroika, these art works have frequently attracted public attention and provoked fierce debates. The Federal Law on Cultural Valuables adopted in 1998 did not cover art works looted by private individuals. Rather, such conflicts have to be solved within the framework of Russian criminal law.

In contrast, other works of art from the same Bremen Kunsthalle collection were restituted from the United States, Ukraine, and Estonia. Another 101 drawings and prints of the collection, seized by another member of Baldin's brigade, were returned from Russia to Bremen in 2000, but that was in “exchange” for an original mosaic from the legendary Amber Chamber. However, despite more than 20 years of efforts by German officials and endless negotiations, the Baldin Collection remains in the Russian Federation. The return of those stolen drawings any time soon now looks highly improbable. The case of the Baldin Collection became the most striking example of the Russian nonrestitution of cultural property looted during World War II.

Type
Articles
Information
International Journal of Cultural Property , Volume 17 , Issue 2: SPECIAL ISSUE: Spoils of War v. Cultural Heritage: The Russian Cultural Property Law in Historical Context , May 2010 , pp. 257 - 290
Copyright
Copyright © International Cultural Property Society 2010

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

A Catalogue of the Works of Art from the Collection of the Kunsthalle Bremen Lost during Evacuation in the Second World War. 2nd ed., rev. Edited by Salzmann, Siegfried and Herzogenrath, Wuff. Bremen: Der Kunstverein/Kunsthalle Bremen, 1997.Google Scholar
Akinsha, Konstantin. “Estonia Returns Missing Durer.” ARTnews, February, 2004.Google Scholar
Akinsha, Konstantin, and Kozlov, Grigorii. “Spoils of War.” ARTnews, April 1991.Google Scholar
Akinsha, Konstantin. Beautiful Loot: The Soviet Plunder of Europe's Art Treasures. New York: Random House, 1995.Google Scholar
Andriasova, Tatiana. “Politicheskie zalozhniki ili proizvedeniia iskusstv?” [Political hostages or art works?]. Moskovskie novosti, no. 20 (16 May 1993).Google Scholar
Babich, Dmitry. “An Exhibit of Goodwill.” Russia Profile (30 October 2008). ⟨http://www.russiaprofile.org/page.php?pageid=Culture+%26+Living&articleid=a1225394731&print=yes⟩.Google Scholar
Bremen-Moskau-Bremen. 101 Blätter von Dürer bis Toulouse-Lautrec-1941 ausgelagert-urückgekehrt 2000. Bremen, Germany: Kunsthalle Bremen, 2000.Google Scholar
“Cultural News: Estonia to Return to Germany Durer's Work.” Eesti Ringvaade/Estonian Review (10–16 November 2003). ⟨http://www.estemb.se/frontpage/estonian_review/newwin-middle50/aid-499⟩.Google Scholar
Dokumentation der durch Auslagerung im 2. Weltkrieg vermissten Kunstwerke der Kunsthalle Bremen/Dokumentatsiìa propavshikh proizvedenii iskusstv bremenskogo muzeia, vyvezennykh vo vremìa II-oi mirovoi voiny. Edited by Salzmann, Siegfried et al. Bremen, Germany: Kunsthalle Bremen, 1991.Google Scholar
“Dozhdutsia li nemtsy nashei kapituliatsii?” [Would Germans at Last See Our Capitulation?]. Argumenty nedeli, no. 40/74 (3 October 2007). ⟨www.argumenti.ru/publications/4820⟩.Google Scholar
Eichwede, Wolfgang. “Restitutions between Ukraine and Germany.” Spoils of War: International Newsletter, no. 1 (1995) ⟨http://spoils.libfl.ru/spoils/eng/spoils1.html⟩.Google Scholar
Eichwede, Wolfgang. “Models of Restitution (Germany, Russia, Ukraine.).” In Spoils of War. World War II and Its Aftermath: The Loss, Reappearance, and Recovery of Cultural Property, edited by Simpson, Elizabeth, et al. New York: Abrams, 1997.Google Scholar
Emelianenko, Vladimir. “Vtoraia popytka” [The Second Try]. Profil' (1 October 2007). ⟨http://www.profile.ru/items/?item=24119&page=2&comment=1⟩.Google Scholar
Fefelov, Andrei. “‘Luchshii nemets’ No 2. Kriminal'nyi skandal vokrug ministra kul'tury” [The “Best German” No 2. The Criminal Scandal around the Minister of Culture]. Zavtra, 12(487), (16 March 2003). ⟨http://www.zavtra.ru/cgi/veil/data/zavtra/03/487/16.html⟩.Google Scholar
Filatova, Natalia. “Mikhail Shvydkoi: ‘Gubenko sam perevez kollektsiiu v Ermitazh’” [Mikhail Shvydkoi: Gubenko Moved the Collection to the Hermitage by Himself]. Itogi, no. 12/354 (25 March 2003). ⟨http://www.itogi.ru/archive/2003/12/79349.html⟩.Google Scholar
Grimsted, Patricia Kennedy. Trophies of War and Empire. The Archival Heritage of Ukraine, World War II, and the International Politics of Restitution. Cambridge, MA: Harvard Papers on Ukrainian Studies, 2001.Google Scholar
Hochfield, Sylvia. “Under the Russian Sofa: 101 Looted Treasures.” ARTnews, April 1993.Google Scholar
Hochfield, Sylvia. “Bremen/Moscow A German-Russian breakthrough.” ARTnews, March 2000.Google Scholar
Kline, Thomas R., and Korte, Willi A.. “U.S. Court Orders Return of Drawings Stolen After World War II to Kunsthalle Bremen.” Spoils of War: International Newsletter, no. 1 (1995). ⟨http://www.dhh-3.de/biblio/bremen/sow1/usorders.html⟩.Google Scholar
Kozlov, Grigorii. “‘Peremeshchennye’ iz Bremena. Sud'ba ‘baldinskoi kollektsii’ s 1945 goda do nashikh dnei” [‘Replaced’ from Bremen. The Fate of the “Baldin Collection” from 1945 to Our Days]. Art Khronika, no. 2 (2003) ⟨http://www.artchronika.ru/item.asp?id=680⟩.Google Scholar
Lemmermeier, Doris. “Country Reports: Germany.” Spoils of War: International Newsletter, no. 0 (1995) ⟨http://spoils.libfl.ru/spoils/eng/spoil0_3.html⟩.Google Scholar
Murre, Aleksandra. “The Return of a Painting by Albrecht Dürer ‘John the Baptist’ from the Art Museum of Estonia to the Former Owner Bremen Kunsthalle.” In Restitution of Confiscated Art Works—Wish or Reality? Documentation, Identification of Cultural Property of the Victims of World War II. Proceedings of the International Academic Conference Held in Liberec on 24–26 October, 2007, 230–34. Prague: Tilia, 2008.Google Scholar
“Rembrandt aus dem Keller.” Der Spiegel, no. 11 (March 1993).Google Scholar
“Return of Durer's Work Shows Good Estonian-German Relations—Schroeder.” Eesti Ringvaade/Estonian Review (6 June 2004). ⟨http://www.estemb.se/estonian_review/aid-474⟩.Google Scholar
Röver-Kann, Anne, ed. Albrecht Dürer: das Frauenbad von 1496: eine Ausstellung um eine wiedergefundene Zeichnung: Kunsthalle Bremen, 11. September bis 4. November 2001. Bremen, Germany: H. M. Hauschild, 2001.Google Scholar
Röver-Kann, Anne. Albrecht Dürer: der heilige Johannes—aus Tallinn zurück!: der heilige Onuphrius und andere Eremiten: Kunsthalle Bremen, 25. Mai bis 4. Juli 2004, eine Ausstellung um ein aus Tallinn zurückgekehrtes Bild. Bremen, Germany: H. M. Hauschild, 2004.Google Scholar
Schossig, Rainer B.Viktor Baldin—Der Mann mit dem Koffer. Die Odysee der 1945 nach Moskau verbrachten Blätter der Kunsthalle Bremen. Bremen, Germany: Hachmannedition, 2006.Google Scholar
Sidorov, Evgenii. “Ministr kul'tury: ‘U menia sviazany ruki’ [Minister of Culture: “My Hands Are Tied”]. Moskovskie novosti, no. 20 (16 May 1993).Google Scholar
“Viktor Baldin Died.” Spoils of War: International Newsletter, no. 4 (August 1997) ⟨http://www.dhh-3.de/biblio/bremen/sow4/contents.html⟩.Google Scholar
Zapadnoevropeiskii risunok XVI-XX vekov iz sobranii Kunstkhalle v Bremene: katalog/Westeuropaische Zeichnung XVI. bis XX. Jahrhundert, Kunsthalle Bremen: Katalog/West European Drawing of XVI–XX centuries, Kunsthalle Collection in Bremen: Catalogue. Compiled by Grigor'eva, I.S., Ilatovskaia, T.A., and Novoselskaia, I.N.. Introductions by Evgenii Sidorov, Klaus Wedemeir, and T.A. Ilatovskaia.Moscow: “Kul'tura,” 1992.Google Scholar