International Journal of Astrobiology

Which exoplanetary systems could harbour habitable planets?

Barrie W. Jones a1, P. Nick Sleep a1 and David R. Underwood a1
a1 Astronomy Group, The Open University, Milton Keynes MK7 6AA, UK e-mail:

Article author query
jones bw   [PubMed][Google Scholar] 
sleep pn   [PubMed][Google Scholar] 
underwood dr   [PubMed][Google Scholar] 


Habitable planets are likely to be broadly Earth-like in composition, mass and size. Masses are likely to be within a factor of a few Earth masses – we call such planets Earth-mass planets. It is important to find such planets. Currently, we do not have sufficiently sensitive techniques to detect planets with such small masses, except in rare circumstances. It is thus necessary to model the known exoplanetary systems to see whether Earth-mass planets could be present. In particular, we need to establish whether such planets could be present in the classical habitable zone (HZ), or whether the giant planets that we know to be present have gravitationally ejected Earth-mass planets or prevented their formation. We have answered this question by applying computer models to the 152 exoplanetary systems known as of 18 April 2006 that are sufficiently well characterized for our analysis. For systems in which there is a giant planet interior to the HZ, which must have got there by migration, there are two cases considered: first, the case when the migration of the giant planet across the HZ has not ruled out the existence of an Earth-mass planet in the HZ; second, the case where it has. In the former case we have found that 60% of the 152 systems offer safe havens to Earth-mass planets across greater than 20% of the HZ width. We regard such systems as being habitable today. We have also estimated whether habitability is possible for 1000 Myr into the past (provided that this period post-dates the heavy bombardment of planets in the HZ). Of the 143 systems that are susceptible to this second analysis, we find that about 50% offer habitability sustained over 1000 Myr. If giant planets interior to the HZ rule Earth-mass planets, then 60% and 50% fall to 7% in both cases.

(Published Online October 12 2006)
(Received July 3 2006)
(Accepted July 31 2006)

Key Words: Earth-like planets; exoplanetary systems; extraterrestrial life; habitable planets; habitable zones; ‘hot’ Jupiters.