Hostname: page-component-8448b6f56d-42gr6 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-20T06:54:27.326Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

‘A Victory for God’: The Scottish Presbyterian Churches and the General Strike of 1926

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  06 February 2009

Stewart J. Brown
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

During the final months of the First World War, the General Assemblies of the two major Presbyterian Churches in Scotland - the established Church of Scotland and the voluntary United Free Church - committed themselves to work for the thorough re- construction of Scottish society. Church leaders promised to work for a new Christian commonwealth, ending the social divisions and class hatred that had plagued pre-war Scottish industrial society. Bound together through the shared sacrifice of the war, the Scottish people would be brought back to the social teachings of Christianity and strive together to realise the Kingdom of God. The Churches would end their deference to the laws of nineteenth-century political economy, with their emphasis on individualism, self-interest and competition, and embrace new impera- tives of collective responsibility and co-operation. Along with the healing of social divisions, church leaders also pledged to end the ecclesiastical divisions in Scottish Presbyterianism. The final months of the war brought a revival of the pre-war movement to unite the Church of Scotland and the United Free Church into a single National Church, and Scottish ecclesiastical leaders held forth to a weary nation the vision of a united National Church leading a covenanted Christian commonwealth in pursuit of social justice and harmony.

Type
Articles
Information
The Journal of Ecclesiastical History , Volume 42 , Issue 4 , October 1991 , pp. 596 - 617
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1991

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Bell, G. K. A., Randall Davidson: archbishop of Canterbury, 2, Oxford 1935, 1304–24;Google ScholarIremonger, F. A., William Temple: archbishop of Canterbury, Oxford 1948, 328–44;Google ScholarMews, S., ‘The Churches’, in M., Morris (ed.), The General Strike, London 1976, 318–37.Google Scholar

2 Harvie, C., No Gods and Precious Few Heroes: Scotland 1914–1980, London 1981, 24;Google ScholarSmout, T. C., A Century of the Scottish People 1830–1950, London 1986, 267.Google Scholar

3 ‘Report of the commission on the war in relation to its spiritual, moral, and social issues’, in Reports on the Schemes of the General Assembly of the Church of Scotland, 1917, 723–58.Google Scholar

4 753.

5 ‘Report of the commission on the war’,Google Scholaribid. 1918, 619–33; 1919, 631–91; Proceedings and Debates of the General Assembly of the United Free Church of Scotland, 1918, 206–11; 1919, 244–7; Paterson, W. P. and D., Watson (eds), Social Evils and Problems, Edinburgh, 1918, esp. pp. 1–27.Google Scholar

6 ‘Report of the commission on the war’, in Reports on the Schemes, 1919, 645.Google Scholar

7 1918, 629.Google Scholar

8 Paterson, W. P., Recent History and the Call to Brotherhood: address delivered at the close of the General Assembly, 05 29, 1919, Edinburgh 1919, 32.Google Scholar

9 32, 8.Google Scholar

10 Tawney, R. H., ‘The abolition of economic controls, 1918–1921’, Economic History Review 13 (1943), 1–30;Google ScholarAbrams, P., ‘The failure of social reform, 1918–1920’, Past and Present 24 (1963), 43–64.Google Scholar

11 Brown, G., Maxton, Edinburgh 1986, 110–11; Cooper, S., ‘John Wheatley: a study in Labour history’, unpublished PhD diss., Glasgow 1973, 130–1.Google Scholar

12 Brown, G., ‘The Labour Party and Political Change in Scotland, 1918–1929: the politics of five elections’, unpublished PhD diss., Edinburgh 1982, 168–91;Google ScholarHutchison, I. G. C., A Political History of Scotland 1832–1924: parties, elections and issues, Edinburgh 1986, 318–28.Google Scholar

13 Middlemas, R. K., The Clydesiders: a left-wing struggle for parliamentary power, London 1965, 88–113; Smout, A Century of the Scottish People, 259–71.Google Scholar

14 ibid270–1; Hutchison, A Political History of Scotland, 277–308.Google Scholar

15 The Diaries of W. P. Paterson, ed. Rawlins, C. L., Edinburgh 1987, 266.Google Scholar

16 Muir, A., John White, London 1958, passim.Google Scholar

17 See, for example the report of White's speech before the Presbytery of Dundee, Scotsman, 25 11. 1925.Google Scholar

18 ‘Man in the Pew’ to John White, 21 02. 1926, John White Papers, New College Library, Edinburgh, Box 24.Google Scholar

19 Bell, Randall Davidson, 2. 1304–18.Google Scholar

20 Telegraphs from Lindsay, A. D. to Professor Archibald Main of Glasgow University, 5, 6 05 1926; Main, A. to White, J., 5 05 1926; White, J. to Main, A., copy, n.d., John White Papers, Box 24.Google Scholar

21 [Anon.], ‘ The Church and the General Strike’, Record of the Home and Foreign Mission Work of the United Free Church 06 1926), 249–52.Google Scholar

82 MacDougall, I., ‘The 1926 General Strike in Edinburgh’, unpublished typescript 1960, National Library of Scotland, Ace. 5695, Edinburgh General Strike, 1926, 32.Google Scholar

23 Bruce, ‘D. Nicol to the Editor’, Scotsman, 20 05 1926.Google Scholar

24 Scotsman, 10 05 1926. See also Lord Sands to John White, , 7 05 1926, John White, Papers, Box 24.Google Scholar

25 Scotsman, 10 05 1926.Google Scholar

26 Scotsman, 12 05 1926.Google Scholar

27 Archie Craig to Harry Galloway, 13 05 1926, Craig Papers, A. C., Bundle 3, New College Library, Edinburgh.Google Scholar

28 Scotsman, 13 05 1926.Google Scholar See also the response of Drummond Shiels, T., the Edinburgh Labour MP, to Miller's letter, Scotsman, 18 05 1926.Google Scholar

29 Scotsman, 13 05 1926Google Scholar

30 Scotsman, 19 05 1926; Glasgow Herald, 19 05 1926.Google Scholar

31 National Union of Scottish Mine Workers, Executive Committee Minutes, 26 05 1926, National Library of Scotland, Dep. 227 (86).Google Scholar

32 Gammie, A., From Pit to Palace: the life story of the Rt. Hon. James Brown, M.P., London [1931], 54–129; Muir, John White, 208;Google ScholarSjolinder, R., Presbyterian Reunion in Scotland, Stockholm 1962, 345–6; W., Knox (ed.), Scottish Labour Leaders, 1918–1919, Edinburgh 1984, 70–1.Google Scholar

33 Muir, , John White, 237; Knox, Scottish Labour Leaders 1918–1939, 58–61.Google Scholar

34 ‘The General Assembly’, Life and Work (07. 1926), 150.Google Scholar

35 Lord Sands [Christopher N.Johnston] to John White, 28 05 1926, John White Papers, Box 24.Google Scholar

36 Sir Adam Nimmo to John White, 28 05 1926, John White, Papers, Box 24.Google Scholar

37 Arthur Steel Maitland to Dr Dunlop, ‘strictly Private and Confidential’, 31 05 1926, John White Papers, Box 24.Google Scholar

38 John White to Sir Adam Nimmo, 29 05 1926, John White Papers, Box 24.Google Scholar

39 Proceedings and Debates, 1926, 105–8;Google ScholarReith, G. M., Reminiscences of the United Free Church General Assembly (1900–1929), Edinburgh 1933, 293–9.Google Scholar

40 Scotsman, 7 06 1926; British Weekly, 10 06 1926.Google Scholar

41 Proceedings and Debates 1926, 273; Reith, Reminiscences, 295–9; John White, ‘speech requesting the General Assembly to welcome Stanley Baldwin to its meeting’, unpublished typescript, John White Papers, Box 23, folder labelled ‘General Assemblies, 1923–27’.Google Scholar

42 Scotsman, 10 06 1926.Google Scholar

43 Scotsman, 19 06 1926; Glasgow Herald, 28 06 1926.Google Scholar

44 Glasgow Herald, 28 06 1926.Google Scholar

45 ‘Report of the committee on church life and social problems’, in Reports to the General Assembly of the United Free Church of Scotland, 1926, no. v. 3–4;Google ScholarHall, J. ‘A great Fifeshire campaign’, The Record of the Home and Foreign Mission Work of the United Free Church of Scotland (04. 1926), 167.Google Scholar

46 Proceedings and Debates, 1926, 278.Google Scholar

47 Gammie, A., Dr. George H. Morrison: his life and work, London, 1928, 123–9.Google Scholar

48 [Anon.] ‘The Church and the General Strike’, 249–52.Google Scholar

49 ‘Report of the committee on church life and social problems’, Reports of the Committees of the General Assembly of the United Free Church 1927, no. v. 1–2;Google ScholarHall, J. D., ‘The Church and the miner: notes on the West Fife campaign’, Record of the Home and Foreign Mission Work of the United Free Church (11. 1926), 478–80.Google Scholar

50 Levitt, I., Poverty and Welfare in Scotland 1890–1948, Edinburgh 1988, 127–30.Google Scholar

51 Forrester, W. R., ‘The West Fife Campaign’, in Gammie, George Morrison, 134.Google Scholar

52 ibid134–8; interview with Professor Norman Porteous, who had been a participant in the West Fife campaign.Google Scholar

53 ‘ It would not be true to say’, reported one of the participants, the Revd Harry Law, ‘that we have touched the heart of the community’: ‘The miners must be won’, Record of the Home and Foreign Mission Work of the United Free Church (10. 1926), 432.Google Scholar

54 Lee, J., Tomorrow is a New Day, London 1939, 90–122.Google Scholar

55 ‘Report of the Committee on Church Life and Social Problems’, Reports of the Committees of the General Assembly of the United Free Church, 1927, no. v. 4;Google ScholarDunnett, A. H., The Church in Changing Scotland, London [1934], 124.Google Scholar

56 T., Drummond Shiels to the Editor, Scotsman, 18 05 1926.Google Scholar

57 Reports on the Schemes, 1926, 619–23.Google Scholar

68 ‘Report of Deputation from the Church of Scotland and the United Free Church of Scotland, received by Sir John Lamb on behalf of the Secretary of State... September 24th, 1926’, typescript, p. u, in John White Papers, Box 9, ‘Irish Immigration’.

59 Maxwell-Arnot, M., ‘social change and the church of Scotland’, in M., Hill (ed.), A Sociological Yearbook of Religion in Britain, 7 (1974), 91–110.Google Scholar

60 Orr, C., ‘A venturing religion’, in Stevenson, J. W. (ed.), The Healing of the Nation: the Scottish Church and a waiting people, Edinburgh 1930, 137.Google Scholar