Journal of Child Language

Do parents lead their children by the hand? 1

a1 University of Chicago

Article author query
ozcaliskan s   [PubMed][Google Scholar] 
goldin-meadow s   [PubMed][Google Scholar] 


The types of gesture+speech combinations children produce during the early stages of language development change over time. This change, in turn, predicts the onset of two-word speech and thus might reflect a cognitive transition that the child is undergoing. An alternative, however, is that the change merely reflects changes in the types of gesture+speech combinations that their caregivers produce. To explore this possibility, we videotaped 40 American child–caregiver dyads in their homes for 90 minutes when the children were 1;2, 1;6, and 1;10. Each gesture was classified according to type (deictic, conventional, representational) and the relation it held to speech (reinforcing, disambiguating, supplementary). Children and their caregivers produced the same types of gestures and in approximately the same distribution. However, the children differed from their caregivers in the way they used gesture in relation to speech. Over time, children produced many more REINFORCING (bike+point at bike), DISAMBIGUATING (that one+point at bike), and SUPPLEMENTARY combinations (ride+point at bike). In contrast, the frequency and distribution of caregivers' gesture+speech combinations remained constant over time. Thus, the changing relation between gesture and speech observed in the children cannot be traced back to the gestural input the children receive. Rather, it appears to reflect changes in the children's own skills, illustrating once again gesture's ability to shed light on developing cognitive and linguistic processes.

(Received August 16 2004)
(Revised March 10 2005)

c1 University of Chicago, Department of Psychology, 5848 S. University Avenue, Chicago, IL 60637, USA. tel: (773) 834 9914; fax: (773) 834 5261; e-mail:


1 We thank Jana Iverson for her input on gesture coding, Kristi Schoendube and Jason Voigt for their administrative and technical help, and the project research assistants, Karyn Brasky, Kristin Duboc, Molly Nikolas, Jana Oberholtzer, Lillia Rissman, and Becky Seibel for their help in collecting and transcribing the data. The research presented in this paper is supported by a grant from NIH (PO1 HD406–05) to Goldin-Meadow.