Behavioral and Brain Sciences

Table of Contents - 1998 - Volume 21, Issue 03  


Open Peer Commentary
Howe et al.: Innate talents

Absurd environmentalism

Douglas K. Detterman a1, Lynne T. Gabriel a1 and Joanne M. Ruthsatz a1
a1 Department of Psychology, Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, OH 44106 dkd2@po.cwru.edu

Abstract

The position advocated in the target article should be called “absurd environmentalism.” Literature showing that general intelligence is related to musical ability is not cited. Also ignored is the heritability of musical talent. Retrospective studies supporting practice over talent are incapable of showing differences in talent, because subjects are self-selected on talent. Reasons for the popularity of absurd environmentalism are discussed.