Du Bois Review: Social Science Research on Race

STATE OF THE ART

CRIME ALERT!

How Thinking about a Single Suspect Automatically Shifts Stereotypes toward an Entire Group

Scott A. Akalisa1 c1, Mahzarin R. Banajia1 and Stephen M. Kosslyna1

a1 Department of Psychology, Harvard University

Abstract

Crime alerts are meant to raise community awareness and identify individual criminal suspects; they are not expected to affect attitudes and beliefs toward the social group to which an individual suspect belongs. However, psychological principles of learning, categorization, and memory predict that what is learned about an instance can color perception of an entire category. At the intersection of psychology, criminal justice, sociology, and media studies, two experiments were conducted to test the effect that providing individual racial identity in crime alerts has on racial group stereotypes. In Experiment 1, participants visualized four scenarios involving Black or White would-be criminals. Results revealed that in the case where Black would-be criminals were made salient in memory, participants demonstrated significantly more negative implicit stereotypes toward Blacks as a group compared with a condition in which White would-be criminals were more salient in memory. In Experiment 2, participants read a written description of a crime scene with a suspect who was either depicted as White or Black, and then imagined the suspect. On both implicit and explicit measures of group stereotypes obtained afterward, participants who read about a Black criminal reported and revealed more anti-Black/pro-White stereotypes than did those who read about a White criminal. Crime alerts that mention racial identity, whatever their benefit, come with the burden of shifting stereotypes of social groups. In this context, the value of racial identification in crime alerts warrants reconsideration.

Keywords

  • Stereotypes;
  • Implicit Attitudes;
  • Crime;
  • IAT;
  • Social Cognition;
  • Imagery

Correspondence:

c1 Scott A. Akalis, 21 South Clark Street, Suite 2900, Chicago, IL 60603. E-mail: akalis@post.harvard.edu

Footnotes

We thank Mickey Muldoon, Hillary Steinbrook, Erlend Svestad, Eva Chen, and Christopher Dial for their help. This research was supported by a National Science Foundation graduate fellowship to Scott A. Akalis, a National Institute of Health grant to Mahzarin R. Banaji, and Grant R01 MH060734 to Stephen M. Kosslyn.

Metrics