Hostname: page-component-7c8c6479df-hgkh8 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-03-27T16:02:28.528Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

The Animal Economy as Object and Program in Montpellier Vitalism

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  01 December 2008

Charles T. Wolfe
Affiliation:
University of Sydney
Motoichi Terada
Affiliation:
Nagoya City University

Argument

Our aim in this paper is to show the importance of the notion of économie animale in Montpellier vitalism as a hybrid concept which brings together the structural and functional dimensions of the living body – dimensions which hitherto had primarily been studied according to a mechanistic model, or were discussed within the framework of Stahlian animism. The celebrated image of the bee-swarm expresses this structural-functional understanding of living bodies quite well: “One sees them press against each other, mutually supporting each other, forming a kind of whole, in which each living part, in its own way, by means of the correspondence and directions of its motions, enables this kind of life to be sustained in the body” (Ménuret 1765c, Enc. XI, 319a). What is important here is that every component part is always a living part, i.e., every structural unit is always functional. Interestingly, while the twin notions of “animal economy” and organisation are presented as improvements over a mechanistic perspective, they are nonetheless compatible with an expanded sense of mechanism, and by extension, with materialism as reflected notably in the writings of Ménuret and Bordeu. We thus propose both a revision and reconstruction of the historical status of the “animal economy,” and a reflection on its conceptual status.

In judging of the beauty of animal bodies, we always carry in our eye the oeconomy of a certain species.

(David Hume [1739] 2000, 3.2.2, 311)

Type
Research Article
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2008

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Balan, Bernard. 1975. “Premières recherches sur l'origine et la formation du concept d'économie animale.” Revue d'histoire des sciences 28:289326.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Barthez, Paul-Joseph. 1806. Nouveaux éléments de la science de l'homme, 2nd ed., 2 vols. Paris: Goujon & Brunot.Google Scholar
Barthez, Paul-Joseph. 1858. Nouveaux éléments de la science de l'homme, 3e édition revue, 2 vols. Paris: Germer Baillière.Google Scholar
Bechtel, William. 2007. “Biological mechanisms: Organized to maintain autonomy.” In Boogerd, F. C. et al. , eds., Systems Biology: Philosophical Foundations. New York: Elsevier. PDF accessed from Bechtel's website at the University of California, San Diego. September 15, 2007. <http://mechanism.ucsd.edu/~bill/research/bechtel.biologicalmechanismsorganization.pdf>' href=https://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=Bechtel,+William.+2007.+“Biological+mechanisms:+Organized+to+maintain+autonomy.”+In+Boogerd,+F.+C.,+eds.,+Systems+Biology:+Philosophical+Foundations.+New+York:+Elsevier.+PDF+accessed+from+Bechtel's+website+at+the+University+of+California,+San+Diego.+September+15,+2007.+>Google Scholar
Blumenbach, Johann Friedrich. 1785. Die medicinische Bibliothek, 3 vols. Göttingen: J. C. Dieterich.Google Scholar
Boerhaave, Herman. 1739. Praelectiones academicae in proprias institutiones rei medicae. Edited by Haller, Albrecht von, 3 vols. Göttingen: Anton Vandenhoeck.Google Scholar
Boerhaave, Herman. 1983. Boerhaave's Orations. Translated and edited by Kegel-Brinkgreve, Elze and Luyendijk-Elshout, Antonie M.. Leiden: E. J. Brill/Leiden University Press.Google Scholar
Bordeu, Théophile. 1751. Recherches anatomiques sur la position des glandes et leur action. Paris: Quillau père.Google Scholar
Bordeu, Théophile. 1754. “Crise (Médecine).” Encyclopédie IV:471489. Paris: Briasson.Google Scholar
Bordeu, Théophile. 1764. Recherches sur quelques points d'histoire de la médecine. Paris: Cailleau.Google Scholar
Bordeu, Théophile. 1818. Œuvres complètes, précédées d'une Notice sur sa vie et ses ouvrages par Monsieur le Chevalier de Richerand, 2 vols. Paris: Caille et Ravier.Google Scholar
Boury, Dominique. 1999. La philosophie médicale de Théophile de Bordeu (1722–1776). Thèse de doctorat. Lille: Université de Lille III.Google Scholar
Boury, Dominique. 2006. “Hippocrate.” In L'Encyclopédie du Rêve de D'Alembert de Diderot, edited by Audidière, Sophie, Bourdin, Jean-Claude and Duflo, Colas, 216218. Paris: Éditions du CNRS.Google Scholar
Brockliss, Laurence and Jones, Colin. 1997. The Medical World of Early Modern France. Oxford: Clarendon Press.Google Scholar
Brown, Theodore M. 1974. “From Mechanism to Vitalism in Eighteenth-Century English Physiology.” Journal of the History of Biology 7 (2):179216.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Brown, Theodore M. [1968] 1981. The Mechanical Philosophy and the Animal Oeconomy. PhD diss. Princeton University; reprint, New York: Arno.Google Scholar
Buffon, Georges-Louis Leclerc de. 1753. Histoire naturelle, générale et particulière, vol. IV. Paris: Imprimerie Royale.Google Scholar
Cabanis, Pierre-Jean-Georges. [1802] 1956. Rapports du physique et du moral de l'homme. In Œuvres philosophiques, edited by Lehec, Claude and Cazeneuve, Jean, 2 vols. Paris: Presses Universitaires de France.Google Scholar
Canguilhem, Georges. [1952] 1975. “Aspects du vitalisme.” In La connaissance de la vie, 2nd edition, 83100. Paris: J. Vrin.Google Scholar
Canguilhem, Georges. [1955] 1977. La formation du concept de réflexe aux XVIIe et XVIIIe siècles, 2nd revised edition. Paris: J. Vrin.Google Scholar
Cassirer, Ernst. 1950. The Problem of Knowledge. Translated by Woglom, William H. and Hendel, Charles W.. New Haven: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
Charleton, Gualtero [Walter]. 1659. Exercitationes physico-anatomicae de oeconomia animali novis in medicina hypothesibus superstructa et mechanice explicata, 2nd edition. Amsterdam: J. Ravesteyn.Google Scholar
Cheung, Tobias. 2006. “From the Organism of a Body to the Body of an Organism: Occurrence and Meaning of the Word ‘Organism’ from the Seventeenth to the Nineteenth Centuries.” British Journal of the History of Science 39:319339.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Chouillet, Jacques. 1984. Diderot poète de l'énergie. Paris: Presses Universitaires de France.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cranefield, Paul F. 1970. “On the Origin of the Phrase nihil est in intellectu.” Journal of the History of Medicine and Allied Sciences 25:7780.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cuvier, Georges. 1810. Rapport historique sur les progrès des sciences naturelles depuis 1789, et sur leur état actuel. Paris: Imprimerie Impériale.Google Scholar
Diderot, Denis. 1975-. Rêve de D'Alembert. In Œuvres complètes, edited by Dieckmann, Herbert, Proust, Jacques, and Varloot, Jean. Paris: Hermann.Google Scholar
Diderot, Denis and D'Alembert, Jean Le Rond, eds. [1751–1780] 1966. Encyclopédie ou Dictionnaire raisonné des arts et des métiers, 35 vols. Paris: Briasson, David, Le Breton & Durand; reprint, Stuttgart/Bad Cannstatt: Frommann.Google Scholar
Duchesneau, François. 1982. La physiologie des Lumières. Empirisme, modèles et théories. The Hague: Martinus Nijhoff.Google Scholar
Duchesneau, François. 1997. “Territoires et frontières du vitalisme, 1750–1850.” In Vitalisms From Haller to the Cell Theory, edited by Cimino, Guido and Duchesneau, François, 297349. Florence: Leo Olschki.Google Scholar
Duchesneau, François and Cimino, Guido, eds. 1997. Vitalisms from Haller to the Cell Theory. Florence: Leo Olschki.Google Scholar
Dumas, Charles-Louis. [1800] 1806. Principes de physiologie, ou introduction à la science expérimentale, philosophique et médicale de l'homme vivant, 2nd edition. Paris: Crapelet.Google Scholar
Encyclopédie méthodique ou par ordre des matières. 1808. Médecine, par une société de médecins, vol. 8. Paris: Veuve Agasse.Google Scholar
Fouquet, Henri. 1765. “Sensibilité, Sentiment (Médecine).” Encyclopédie XV:3852. Paris: Briasson.Google Scholar
Fouquet, Henri. 1803 [an XI]. Discours sur la clinique. Montpellier: Izar & Ricard.Google Scholar
Gaissinovitch, Abba E. 1968. “Le rôle du newtonianisme dans la renaissance des idées épigénétiques en embryologie au dix-huitième siècle.” In Actes du 11e congrès international d'histoire des sciences, Varsovie-Cracovie, 1965, vol. V: Histoire des sciences biologiques, 105110. Wroclaw: Éditions de l'Académie Polonaise des Sciences.Google Scholar
Gaukroger, Stephen. 2000. “The Resources of a Mechanist Physiology and the Problem of Goal-Directed Processes.” In Descartes’ Natural Philosophy, edited by Gaukroger, Stephen, Schuster, John and Sutton, John, 383400. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Gierer, Alfred. 1996. “Organisms-Mechanisms: Stahl, Wolff and the Case against Reductionist Exclusion.” Science in Context 9 (4):511528.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gilbert, Scott F. and Sarkar, Sahotra. 2000. “Embracing Complexity: Organicism for the 21st Century.” Developmental Dynamics 219:19.3.0.CO;2-A>CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Goethe, Johann Wolfgang von. 1887–1919. Goethes Werke. Herausgegeben im Auftrage der Grossherzogin Sophie von Sachsen, 143 vols. Weimar: Hermann Böhlau.Google Scholar
Guillo, Dominique. 2003. Les figures de l'organisation. Sciences de la vie et sciences sociales au XIXe siècle. Paris: PUF.Google Scholar
Hall, Thomas S. 1968. “On Biological Analogs of Newtonian Paradigms.” Philosophy of Science 35 (1):627.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hall, Thomas S. 1969. Ideas of Life and Matter: Studies in the History of General Physiology, 2 vols. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Haller, Albrecht von. 1747. Primae lineae physiologiae in usum praelectionum academicarum auctae et emendatae. Göttingen: Anton Vandenhoeck.Google Scholar
Haller, Albrecht von. 1752. Elémens de physiologie; ou, Traité de la structure et des usages des differentes parties du corps humain. Traduit du latin par Pierre Tarin. Paris: Guillyn.Google Scholar
Haller, Albrecht von. 1755. Dissertation sur les parties irritables et sensibles des animaux. Traduit du Latin par M. Tissot (exposé à la Société Royale des Sciences de Göttingen, 1752). Lausanne: Marc-Michel Bousquet.Google Scholar
Haller, Albrecht von. [1755] 1981. A Dissertation on the Sensible and Irritable Parts of Animals. London: J. Nourse; reprinted in The Natural Philosophy of Albrecht von Haller, edited by Shirley, A. Roe. New York: Arno Press.Google Scholar
Haller, Albrecht von. 1772. “Faculté vitale.” In Encyclopédie, ou dictionnaire universel raisonné des connoissances humaines (42 vols. and 6 vols. of supplements, 1770–1779), vol. XVII:244b-250a. Yverdon: F. B. De Félice.Google Scholar
Haller, Albrecht von. 1777. “Irritabilité.” In Supplément à l'Encyclopédie ou Dictionnaire raisonné des arts et des métiers, par une Société de Gens de Lettres, vol. III:663665. Amsterdam: Marc-Michel Rey.Google Scholar
Hamilton, William. 1840. Fragments de philosophie. Traduits de l'anglais par Louis Peisse, avec une préface, des notes et un appendice du traducteur. Paris: Ladrange.Google Scholar
Han, Hee-Jin. 2004. Le programme de recherche vitaliste dans les sciences bio-médicales: une étude historico-épistémologique du vitalisme français au XVIIIe siècle. Thèse de doctorat. Paris: Université de Paris I.Google Scholar
Hoffmann, Friedrich. 1749. Operum omnium physico-medicorum supplementum primum. Geneva: Fratres De Tournes.Google Scholar
Hume, David. [1739] 2000. A Treatise of Human Nature. Edited by Norton, David Fate. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Huneman, Philippe. 2007. “‘Animal Economy’: Anthropology and the Rise of Psychiatry from the Encyclopédie to the Alienists.” In The Anthropology of the Enlightenment, edited by Wolff, Larry and Cipolloni, Marco, 262276. Stanford: Stanford University Press.Google Scholar
Ibrahim, Annie. 1999. “Leibniz et la machine naturelle. Trame de la vie et chaine des vivants.” Studia Leibnitiana, Supplementa 34: L'actualité de Leibniz: les deux labyrinthes, 643656. Stuttgart: Felix Steiner.Google Scholar
Kafker, Frank A. and Kafker, Serena L.. 1988. The Encyclopedists as Individuals: A Biographical Dictionary of the Authors of the Encyclopédie. Oxford: Voltaire Foundation.Google Scholar
Kaitaro, Timo. 1997. Diderot's Holism: Philosophical Anti-Reductionism and Its Medical Background. Frankfurt am Main: Peter Lang.Google Scholar
Kant, Immanuel. 1968. Träume eines Geistersehers, erläutert durch Träume der Metaphysik [1766], in Kants gesammelte Schriften. Hrsg. von der Königlich Preussischen Akademie der Wissenschaften zu Berlin, vol. II. Reprint, Berlin: de Gruyter.Google Scholar
Kuhn, Thomas S. 1976. “Mathematical vs. Experimental Traditions in the Development of Physical Science.” Journal of Interdisciplinary History 7 (1):131.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
de La Caze, Louis. 1755. Idée de l'homme physique et moral pour servir d'introduction à un traité de médecine. Paris: Guérin & Delatour.Google Scholar
Larson, James L. 1979. “Vital Forces: Regulative Principles or Constitutive Agents? A Strategy in German Physiology, 1786–1802.” Isis 70 (2):235249.Google ScholarPubMed
Lavabre-Bertrand, Thierry. 1992. La philosophie médicale de l'école de Montpellier au XIXe siècle. Thèse de doctorat. Paris: École Pratique des Hautes Études, IVe Section.Google Scholar
Leduc-Fayette, Denise. 1978. “La Mettrie et Descartes.” Europe, special issue on Descartes, 37–48.Google Scholar
Leibniz, Gottfried Wilhelm. 1978. Die philosophischen Schriften. Edited by Gerhardt, G. J., 7 vols. Reprint, Hildesheim/New York: Georg Olms.Google Scholar
Lemoine, Albert. 1864. Le vitalisme et l'animisme de Stahl. Paris: Germer Baillière.Google Scholar
Lenoir, Timothy. 1982. The Strategy of Life: Teleology and Mechanism in Nineteenth Century German Biology. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Lesch, John K. 1984. Science and Medicine in France: The Emergence of Experimental Physiology, 1790–1855. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Littré, Émile and Robin, Charles. 1863. Dictionnaire de médecine, 12th edition. Paris: J.-B. Baillière.Google Scholar
Machamer, Peter, Darden, Lindley, and Craver, Carl. 2000. “Thinking about Mechanisms.” Philosophy of Science 67:125.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Malaterre, Christophe. 2007. “Le ‘néo-vitalisme’ au XIXe siècle: une seconde école française de l'émergence?” Bulletin d'histoire et d'épistémologie des sciences de la vie 14 (1):2544.Google Scholar
Mandeville, Bernard. [1730] 1976. A Treatise of the Hypochondriack and Hysterick Diseases, in Three Dialogues, second corrected edition. London: Tonson; reprint, Delmar, NY: Scholars’ Reprints.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Martin, Julian. 1990. “Sauvages’ Nosology: Medical Enlightenment in Montpellier.” In The Medical Enlightenment of the Eighteenth Century, edited by Cunningham, Andrew and French, Roger, 111138. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Mayr, Ernst. 1997. This is Biology: The Science of the Living World. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Ménuretde Chambaud, Jean-Joseph de Chambaud, Jean-Joseph. 1765a. “Inflammation, Maladies Inflammatoires (Médecine).” Encyclopédie VIII:708720. Paris: Briasson.Google Scholar
Ménuretde Chambaud, Jean-Joseph de Chambaud, Jean-Joseph. 1765b. “Observateur (Gram. Physiq. Méd.).” Encyclopédie XI:310313. Paris: Briasson.Google Scholar
Ménuretde Chambaud, Jean-Joseph de Chambaud, Jean-Joseph. 1765c. “Observation (Gram. Physiq. Méd.).”Encyclopédie XI:313321. Paris: Briasson.Google Scholar
Ménuretde Chambaud, Jean-Joseph de Chambaud, Jean-Joseph. 1765d. “Œconomie Animale (Médecine).”Encyclopédie XI:360366. Paris: Briasson.Google Scholar
Ménuretde Chambaud, Jean-Joseph de Chambaud, Jean-Joseph. 1765e. “Pouls (Méd. Econom. anim. Physiol. Séméiot.).” Encyclopédie XIII:205240. Paris: Briasson.Google Scholar
Ménuretde Chambaud, Jean-Joseph de Chambaud, Jean-Joseph. 1765f. “Spasme (Médec. Patholog.).” Encyclopédie XV:434438. Paris: Briasson.Google Scholar
Ménuret de Chambaud, Jean-Joseph. 1765g. “Ténesme (Médecine).” Encyclopédie XVI:136137. Paris: Briasson.Google Scholar
Ménuret de Chambaud, Jean-Joseph. 1765h. “Nosologie.” Encyclopédie XI:232a. Paris: Briasson.Google Scholar
Ménuretde Chambaud, Jean-Joseph de Chambaud, Jean-Joseph. 1765i. “Mort.” Encyclopédie X:718727. Paris: Briasson.Google Scholar
Monti, Maria-Teresa. 1997. “Les dynamismes du corps et les forces du vivant dans la physiologie de Haller.” In Vitalisms from Haller to the Cell Theory, edited by Cimino, Guido and Duchesneau, François, 4166. Florence: Leo Olschki.Google Scholar
Moravia, Sergio. 1978. “From Homme-Machine to Homme Sensible. Changing Eighteenth-Century Models of Man's ImageJournal of the History of Ideas 39 (1):4560.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Naigeon, Jacques-André. [1821] 1970. Mémoires historiques et philosophiques sur la vie et les ouvrages de Diderot. Paris: Brière; reprint, Geneva: Slatkine Reprints.Google Scholar
Newton, Isaac. [1731] 1952. Opticks, 4th edition. Edited by Cohen, I. Bernard, et al. New York: Dover.Google Scholar
Putnam, Hilary. 1975. “Philosophy and Our Mental Life.” In Mind, Language, and Reality. Philosophical Papers, edited by Putnam, Hilary, vol. 2, 291303. Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Raynaud, Dominique. 1998. “La controverse entre organicisme et vitalisme. Étude de sociologie des sciences.” Revue française de Sociologie 39 (4):721750.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Reill, Peter Hanns. 2005. Vitalizing Nature in the Enlightenment. Berkeley: University of California Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rey, Roselyne. 1987. Naissance et développement du vitalisme en France, de la deuxième moitié du 18e siècle à la fin du Premier Empire. Thèse de doctorat, 3 vols. Paris: Université de Paris I.Google Scholar
Rey, Roselyne. 1992a. “Buffon et le vitalisme.” In Buffon 88, edited by Gayon, Jean, 399414. Paris: J. Vrin.Google Scholar
Rey, Roselyne. 1992b. “Anamorphoses d'Hippocrate au XVIIIe siècle.” In Maladie et maladies, histoire et conceptualisation. Mélanges en l'honneur de Mirko Grmek, edited by Gourevitch, Danielle, 257276. Geneva: Droz.Google Scholar
Rey, Roselyne. 2000. Naissance et développement du vitalisme en France de la deuxième moitié du 18e siècle à la fin du Premier Empire. Oxford: Voltaire Foundation (Abridged version of Rey 1987).Google Scholar
Robinson, Bryan. 1732. Treatise on the Animal Oeconomy. Dublin: George Grierson.Google Scholar
Roe, Shirley A. 1984. “Anatomia Animata: The Newtonian Physiology of Albrecht von Haller.” In Transformation and Tradition in The Sciences: Essays in Honor of I. Bernard Cohen, edited by Mendelsohn, Everett, 274300. Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Roger, Jacques. 1980. “The Living World.” In The Ferment of Knowledge: Studies in the Historiography of Eighteenth Century Science, edited by Rousseau, G. S. & Porter, Roy, 255284. Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Salomon-Bayet, Claire. 1978. L'institution de la science et l'expérience du vivant. Méthode et expérience à l'Académie Royale des Sciences, 1666–1793. Paris: Flammarion.Google Scholar
Salomon-Bayet, Claire. 1981. “1802. ‘Biologie’ et medicine.” In Epistemological and Social Problems of the Sciences in the Early Nineteenth Century, edited by Jahnke, Hans N. and Otte, Michael, 3554. Dordrecht: Reidel.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sauvages, François Boissier de. 1752. Dissertation sur les médicaments qui affectent certaines parties du corps humain plutôt que d'autres . . . Bordeaux: P. Brun.Google Scholar
Sauvages, François Boissier de. 1770. Les Chefs-dœuvre de Monsieur de Sauvages, ou Recueil de dissertations qui ont remporté le prix dans différentes Académies, auxquelles on a ajouté la Nourrice marâtre du chevalier Linné, 2 vols. Lausanne et Lyon: V. Reguilliat.Google Scholar
Sauvages, François Boissier de. [1763] 1771. Nosologie méthodique, dans laquelle les maladies sont rangées par classes, suivant le systême de Sydenham, & l'ordre des Botanistes, 3 vols. Paris: Hérissant fils.Google Scholar
Schofield, Robert E. 1970. Mechanism and Materialism: British Natural Philosophy in an Age of Reason. Princeton: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Sonntag, Otto, ed. 1983. The Correspondence between Albrecht von Haller and Charles Bonnet. Bern: Huber.Google Scholar
Stahl, Georg-Ernest. [1706a] 1859. De la différence entre le mécanisme et l'organisme (Disquisitio de Mechanismi et Organismi Diversitate). In Œuvres médico-philosophiques et pratiques, translated by Blondin, Théodore, edited by Boyer, Louis, vol. 2. Paris: J.-B. Baillière.Google Scholar
Stahl, Georg-Ernest. [1706b] 1859. De la nécessité d'éloigner de la doctrine médicale tout ce qui lui est étranger (Paraenesis ad aliena a medica doctrina arcendum). In Œuvres médico-philosophiques et pratiques, translated by Blondin, Théodore, edited by Boyer, Louis, vol. 2. Paris: J.-B. Baillière.Google Scholar
Stahl, Georg-Ernest. [1730] 1860. Vraie théorie médicale (Theoria medica vera). In Œuvres médico-philosophiques et pratiques, translated by Blondin, Théodore, edited by Boyer, Louis, vol. 3. Paris: J.-B. Baillière.Google Scholar
Steinke, Hubert. 2001. “Haller's Concepts of Irritability and Sensibility and their Reception in France.” In Mécanisme et vitalisme, edited by Saad, Mariana, Dossier in La lettre de la Maison française d'Oxford 14:37–69.Google Scholar
Steinke, Hubert. 2005. Irritating Experiments: Haller's Concept and the European Controversy on Irritability and Sensibility, 1750–90. Amsterdam and New York: Rodopi.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Symons, John. Forthcoming. “Functionalism and Fallibility.” Southwest Philosophical Studies.Google Scholar
Terada, Motoichi. 2006. “La sphygmologie chinoise et la mise au point d'une nouvelle conception vitaliste de l'économie animale par des vitalistes montpelliérains.” Archives Internationales d'Histoire des Sciences 56/156–157:149163.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Toellner, Richard. 1977. “Mechanismus – Vitalismus: Ein Paradigmawechsel? Testfall Haller.” In Die Struktur wissenschaftlicher Revolutionen und die Geschichte der Wissenschaften, edited by Diemer, Alwin, 3365. Meisenheim am Glan: Anton Hain.Google Scholar
Wellman, Kathleen. 2003. “Materialism and Vitalism.” In The Oxford Companion to the History of Modern Science, editor in Heilbron, chief John L.. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Accessed at Oxford Reference Online. September 15, 2007. http://www.oxfordreference.com.Google Scholar
Williams, Elizabeth A. 2003. A Cultural History of Medical Vitalism in Enlightenment Montpellier. Burlington: Ashgate.Google Scholar
Wolfe, Charles T. 2002. Review of Timo Kaitaro, Diderot's Holism. Philosophical Anti-Reductionism and its Medical Background in British Journal for the History of Philosophy 10 (2):315318.Google Scholar
Wolfe, Charles T. 2006a. “L'organisme, une fiction instrumentale?Les fictions de la science, Sciences et Avenir Hors-Série 147:41.Google Scholar
Wolfe, Charles T. 2006b. “Cause et Effet.” In L'Encyclopédie du Rêve de D'Alembert de Diderot, edited by Audidière, Sophie, Bourdin, Jean-Claude and Duflo, Colas, 7882. Paris: Éditions du CNRS.Google Scholar