Hostname: page-component-8448b6f56d-mp689 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-24T00:31:11.271Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Word of Minos: the Minoan Contribution to Mycenaean Greek and the Linguistic Geography of the Bronze Age Aegean

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  22 December 2008

Colin Renfrew
Colin Renfrew
Affiliation:
McDonald Institute for Archaeological Research Downing Street Cambridge CB2 3ER
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The question of the supposedly pre-Greek language or languages of the Aegean, in its wider historical and cultural context, has not been systematically addressed since the decipherment of the Linear B script, other than in the philological studies of DA. Hester. Here it is argued that the time is ripe for a new synthesis between the linguistic and the cultural evidence. The language of the Minoan Linear A script, that is (it is here assumed) the Minoan language of the palaces, is here identified as making the principal contribution to the so-called ‘pre-Greek’ vocabulary of the Greek language, thus constituting not a linguistic substratum of earlier date but an adstratum, which developed during their co-existence in the Aegean during the Bronze Age. This may be seen as the linguistic component in the ‘Versailles effect’ of Minoan palatial influence within the Aegean, which reached its apogee in the Late Bronze 1 period, a view anticipated in some respects in the work of some earlier writers notably G. Glotz.

Such an approach focuses attention more clearly on the intellectual and ideological contributions of Minoan culture to the emerging Mycenaean civilization, rather than on the piecemeal acquisition of material items, without however assigning a secondary or subordinate role to the mainland communities in their own transition towards state society. One important consequence of the argument is to diminish (or even eliminate) the case for a significant chronologically pre-Greek element in the Greek language. One principal argument against the very early, probably Neolithic arrival of proto-Greek (or proto-Indo-European) speakers into mainland Greece is thereby removed. The resulting simplification in the linguistic picture of the Bronze Age Aegean proposed here carries implications also for that of western Anatolia and for the great antiquity there of the Luwian language. It opens questions also about the affinities of the presumed Anatolianancestor of the Minoan (or proto-Minoan) language.

Type
Articles
Information
Cambridge Archaeological Journal , Volume 8 , Issue 2 , October 1998 , pp. 239 - 264
Copyright
Copyright © The McDonald Institute for Archaeological Research 1998

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Barber, E. J. W., 1975. The Proto-Indo-European notion of cloth and clothing. Journal of Indo-European Studies 3, 294–320.Google Scholar
Barber, E. J. W., 1991. Prehistoric Textiles, the Development of Cloth in the Neolithic and Bronze Ages, with Special Reference to the Aegean. Princeton (NJ): Princeton University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Barber, E. J. W., 1994. Women's Work, the First 20,000 Years. New York (NY): W. W. Norton.Google Scholar
Bernal, M., 1987. Black Athena: the Afroasiatic Roots of Classical Civilization, I. London: Free Association Books.Google Scholar
Briquel, D., 1992. Etrusque(s) et Indo-Européen(s). Topoi, Orient Occident (Lyon) 2, 122–30.Google Scholar
Broodbank, C. & Strasser, T. F., 1991. Migrant farmers and the Neolithic colonization of Crete. Antiquity 65, 233–45.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brown, E. L., 1990. Traces of Luwian dialect in Cretan text and toponyms. Studi Mycenei ed Egeo-Anatolici 28, 225–38.Google Scholar
Carruba, O., 1995. L'arrivo dei Greci, le migrazioni Indoeuropee e il ‘ritorno’ degli Eraclidi. Athenaeum 83, 5–44.Google Scholar
Caskey, J. L., 1964. Greece, Crete and the Aegean Islands in the Early Bronze Age, in Cambridge Ancient History I, eds. Edwards, I. E. S., Gadd, C. J. & Hammond, N. G. L.. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, ch. 26, 771–807. (Initially published as separate fascicule.)Google Scholar
Chadwick, J., 1963. The prehistory of the Greek language, inCambridge Ancient History II, eds. Edwards, I. E. S., Gadd, C. J. & Hammond, N. G. L.. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 805–19.Google Scholar
Chadwick, J., 1976. Who were the Dorians? Parola del Passato 31, 103–17.Google Scholar
Chadwick, J., 1985. Les origines de la langue grecque. Comptes Rendus, Académie des Inscriptions et BellesLettres 1985, 697–704.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cherry, J. F., 1990. The first colonisation of the Mediterranean islands: a review of recent research. Journal of Mediterranean Archaeology 3, 145–221.Google Scholar
Crossland, R. A., 1967. Immigrants from the north, in Cam-bridge Ancient History I, part 2, eds. Edwards, I. E. S., Gadd, C. J. & Hammond, N. G. L.. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 824–76. (Originally published as separate fascicule.)Google Scholar
Crossland, R. A. & Birchall, A. (eds.), 1973. Bronze Age Migrations in the Aegean. London: Duckworth.Google Scholar
Demakopoulou, K., 1996. The Aidonia Treasure. Athens: National Archaeological Museum.Google Scholar
Diakonoff, I. M., 1990. Language contacts in the Caucasus and the Near East, in Markey, & Greppin, (eds.), 53–62.Google Scholar
Diakonoff, I. M. & Starostin, S. A., 1986. Hurro-Urartian as an Eastern Caucasian Language. Munich: Kitzinger.Google Scholar
Dickinson, O., 1977. The Origins of Mycenaean Civilisation. (Studies in Mediterranean Archaeology 49.) Göteborg: Paul Aströms Forlag.Google Scholar
Dickinson, O., 1994. The Aegean Bronze Age. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Dixon, R. M. W., 1997. The Rise and Fall of Languages. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dolgopolsky, A., 1988. The Indo-European homeland and lexical contacts of Proto-Indo-European with other languages. Mediterranean Language Review 3, 7–31.Google Scholar
Dolgopolsky, A., 1993. More about the Indo-European homeland problem. Mediterranean Language Review 6–7, 230–46.Google Scholar
Dragona-Latsoudi, A., 1979. Mykenaikos kitharodos apo ti Nauplia. Archaiologike Ephemeris 1979, 86–98.Google Scholar
Drews, R., 1988. The Coming of the Creeks. Princeton (NJ): Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Driessen, J. & Macdonald, C. F., 1997. The Troubled Island, Minoan Crete Before and After the Santorini Eruption. (Aegaeum 17.) Liege: University of Liège.Google Scholar
Duchesne-Guillemin, M., 1981. Music in ancient Mesopotamia and Egypt. World Archaeology 13, 287–97.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Evans, A. J., 1904. The significance of the marks, in Chapter V: ‘The pottery marks’, in Excavations at Phylakopi in Melos, by Atkinson, T. D., Mackenzie, D. et al. . (Society for the Promotion of Hellenic Studies, Supplementary Paper 4.) London: Macmillan, 181–5.Google Scholar
C., Forster Smith, 1919. Translation of Tliucycides. (Loeb Classical Library.) Cambridge (MA): Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Gamkrelidze, T. V., 1990. On the problem of an Asiatic original homeland of the Proto-Indo-Europeans, in Markey & Greppin, (eds.), 5–14.Google Scholar
Gamkrelidze, T.V.. & Ivanov, V. V., 1985a. Indoevropejskij jazyk i indoevropejcy [Die Indo-European Language and the Indo-European] Tblisi: Tblisi University.Google Scholar
Gamkrelidze, T.V. & Ivanov, V.V., 1985b. The ancient Near East and the Indo-European question. Journal of Indo European Studies 13, 3–48.Google Scholar
Gamkrelidze, T. V. & Ivanov, V. V., 1985c. The migrations of tribes speaking Indo-European dialects from their original homeland in the Near East to their historical habitations in Eurasia. Journal of Indo-European Studies 13, 49–91.Google Scholar
Gamkrelidze, T. V. & Ivanov, V. V., 1995. Indo-European and the Indo-Europeans. (Trends in Linguistic Studies, Monographs 80.) Mouton: de Gruyter.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gejvall, N-G., 1969. Lerna: a Preclassical Site in the Argolid, vol. I: the Fauna. Princeton (NJ): American School of Classical Studies at Athens.Google Scholar
Georgiev, V. I., 1973. The arrival of the Greeks in Greece: the linguistic evidence, in Crossland, & Birchall, (eds.), 243–53.Google Scholar
Getz-Preziosi, P., 1987. Sculptors of the Cyclades: Individual and Tradition in the Third Millennium Bc. Ann Arbor (MI): University of Michigan Press.Google Scholar
Glotz, G., 1925. The Aegean Civilisation. London: Kegan Paul, Trench, Trubner.Google Scholar
Godley, A. D., 1920. Translation of Herodotus. (Loeb Classical Library.) Cambridge (MA): Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Greenberg, J., 1987. Language in the Americas. Stanford (CA): Stanford University Press.Google Scholar
Hägg, R., 1984. Degree and character of the Minoan influence on the mainland, in Hägg, & Marinatos, (eds.), 119–22.Google Scholar
Hägg, R., 1985. Mycenaean religion, the Helladic and Minoan components, in Linear B: a 1984 Survey, eds. Davies, A. Morpurgo & Duhoux, Y.. Louvain-laNeuve: Cabay, 202–25.Google Scholar
Hägg, R. & Marinatos, N. (eds.), 1984. The Minoan Thalassocracy: Myth and Reality. Stockholm: Paul Aströms Forlag.Google Scholar
Haley, J. B. & Blegen, C. W., 1928. The coming of the Greeks. American Journal of Archaeology 32, 141–54.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hall, J. M., 1997. Ethnic Identity in Greek Antiquity. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hall, J. M., 1998. Review Feature of Ethnic Identity in Greek Antiquity. Cambridge Archaeological Journal 8 (2), 265–83.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Harmatta, J., 1964, Das Pelasgische und die alten Balkansprachen. Linguistique Balkanique (Balkansko Ezikoznaniye) 9(1), 41–7.Google Scholar
Harmatta, J., 1991. Das Hethetische-Luwische und die Kefti-Sprache. Annales A. Académie scienlifique Hungria 31, 251–6.Google Scholar
Hester, D. A., 1957. Pre-Greek place names in Greece and Asia Minor. Revue Hitlite el Asianique 15, 107–19.Google Scholar
Hester, D. A., 1965. ‘Pelasgian’: a new Indo-European language? Lingua 13, 335–84.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Holmes, P. & Coles, J. M., 1981. Prehistoric brass instruments. World Archaeology 13, 280–86.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hood, M. S. F., 1953. A Mycenaean cavalryman. Annual of the British School of Archaeology at Athens 58, 84–93.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hood, M. S. F., 1990. Settlers in Crete c. 3000 Bc. Cretan Studies 2, 151–8.Google Scholar
Huxley, G., 1961. Crete and the Luwians. Oxford: Vincent-Baxter Press.Google Scholar
Ivanov, V. V., 1985. Ob otnosenii xattskogo jazyka k severozapanokavkavzskim. Drevnaja Anatolija (Moscow) 2, 25–59.Google Scholar
Jones, H. L., 1969. The Geography of Strabo. (Loeb Classical Library V.) London: Heinemann.Google Scholar
Kilian, K., 1988. The emergence of wanax ideology in the Mycenaean palaces. Oxford Journal of Archaeology 7, 291–302.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Killen, J. T., 1964. The wool industry of Crete in the late Bronze Age. Annual of the British School al Athens 59, 1–15.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Killen, J. T., 1979. The Knossos Ld(1) tablets, in Risch, & Muhlstein, (eds.), 151–81.Google Scholar
Killen, J. T., 1995. Some further thoughts on ‘collectors’, in Politeia: Society and State in the Aegean Bronze Age, eds. Laffineur, R. & Niemeier, W. D.. (Aegaeum 12.) Liège: University of Liege, 213–26.Google Scholar
Landels, J. G., 1981. The reconstruction of ancient Greek auloi. World Archaeology 13, 298–302.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Laroche, E., 1961. Etudes de toponymie anatolienne. Revue Hittite el Asianique 19, 57–98.Google Scholar
Laserre, F., 1988. Musica babilonese e musica greca, in La Musica in Grecia, eds. Gentile, B. & Pretagostini, R.. Rome: La Terza, 72–93.Google Scholar
Lorimer, H. L., 1950. Homer and the Monuments. London: Macmillan.Google Scholar
Lund, C, 1981. The archaeomusicology of Scandinavia. World Archaeology 13, 246–301.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Luraghi, S., 1998. The Anatolian languages, in The Indo-European Languages, eds. Ramat, G. A. & Ramat, P.. London: Routledge, 169–96.Google Scholar
Maas, M. & Snyder, J. M., 1989. Stringed Instruments of Ancient Greece. New Haven (CT): Yale University Press.Google Scholar
Malaspina, P., Cruciani, F., Ciminelli, B. M. et al. , in press. Network analysis of Y-chromosomal types in Europe, North Africa and West Asia reveal specific patterns of geographical distribution. American Journal of Human Genetics.Google Scholar
Markey, T.L. & Greppin, J.A.C. (eds.), 1990. When Worlds Collide: the Bellagio Papers. Ann Arbor (MI): Karoma Publishers.Google Scholar
Masson, E., 1967. Recherches sur les plus anciens emprunts sémitiques en grec. Paris: Klineksieck.Google Scholar
Masson, O., 1991. Anatolian languages, in Cambridge Ancient History III, eds. Boardman, J., Edwards, I.E.S., Hammond, N.G.L., Sollberger, E. & Walker, C.B.F.. (2nd edition.) Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 666–76.Google Scholar
Mee, C., 1988. A Mycenaean thalassocracy in the eastern Aegean?, in Problems in Greek Prehistory, eds. French, E.B. & Wardle, K.A.. Bristol: Bristol Classical Papers, 301–5.Google Scholar
Meillet, A., 1930. Aperçu d'une histoire de la langue Grecque. (3rd edition.) Paris: Hachette.Google Scholar
Mellink, M., 1991. The native kingdoms of Anatolia, in Cambridge Ancient History, III part 2, eds. Boardman, J., Edwards, I.E.S., Hammond, N.G.L., Solberger, E. & Walker, C.B.F.. (2nd edition.) Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 619–65.Google Scholar
Michaelides, S., 1978. The Music of Ancient Greece: an Encyclopedia. London: Faber.Google Scholar
Morpurgo, Davis A., 1979. Terminology of power and terminology of work, in Risch, & Muhlstein, (eds.), 98–9.Google Scholar
Morpurgo, Davies A., 1986. The linguistic evidence — is there any?, in The End of the Early Bronze Age in the Aegean, ed. Cadogan, G.. Leiden: Brill, 93–123.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Murray, A.T., 1995. Translation of Homer, The Odyssey. (2nd edition.) (Loeb Classical Library II.) Cambridge (MA): Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Niemeier, W.-D., 1996. A linear A inscription from Miletus. Kadmos 35, 87–98.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Owens, G.A., 1996. Evidence for the Minoan language (1): the Minoan libation formula. Cretan Studies 5, 163–206.Google Scholar
Palaima, P., 1995. The nature of the Mycenaean wanax: non-Indo-European origins and priestly functions, in Rehak, (ed.), 119–42.Google Scholar
Palmer, L.R., 1955. Achaeans and lndo-Europcans. Oxford: Clarendon Press.Google Scholar
Palmer, L.R., 1958. Luvian and Linear A. Transactions of the Philological Society (1958), 75–100.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Palmer, L.R., 1965. Mycenaeans and Minoans. (2nd edition). London: Faber.Google Scholar
Pope, M. & Raison, J., 1978. Linear A: changing perspectives, in Etudes Minoennes I, ed. Duhoux, Y.. Louvain: Editions Peeters, 5–64.Google Scholar
Probonas, J.K., 1992. Le mot mycénien a-sa-mi-to comme indice de l'origine mycénienne de l'épopée, in Mykenaika, ed. Olivier, J.-P.. (Bulletin de Correspondence Hellenique Supplément XXV.) Paris: Boccard, 509–42.Google Scholar
Puhvel, J., 1994. Anatolian: autochthonous or interloper? Journal of Indo-European Studies 22, 251–63.Google Scholar
Ray, J.D., 1982. The Carian inscriptions from Egypt. Journal of Egyptian Archaeology 68, 181–98.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ray, J.D., 1987. The Egyptian approach to Carian. Kadmos 26, 98–103.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ray, J.D., 1990. An outline of Carian grammar. Kadmos 29, 54–83.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rehak, P. (ed.), 1995. The Role of the Ruler in Aegean Prehistory. (Aegaeum 11.) Liège: University of Liège.Google Scholar
Renfrew, C., 1964. Crete and the Cyclades before Rhadamanthus. Kretika Chronika 18, 107–41.Google Scholar
Renfrew, C., 1969. The development and chronology of the Early Cycladic figurines. American Journal of Archaeology 73, 1–32.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Renfrew, C., 1972. The Emergence of Civilisation, the Cyclades and the Aegean in the Third Millennium Bc. London: Methuen.Google Scholar
Renfrew, C., 1973. Problems in the general correlation of archaeological and linguistic strata in prehistoric Greece: the model of autochthonous origin, in Crossland, & Birchall, (eds.), 263–76.Google Scholar
Renfrew, C., 1987. Archaeology and Language, the Puzzle of Indo-European Origins. London: Jonathan Cape.Google Scholar
Renfrew, C., 1994. The archaeology of identity, in The Tanner Lectures on Human Values, vol. 15, ed. Peterson, G.B.. Salt Lake City (UT): University of Utah Press, 285–348.Google Scholar
Renfrew, C., 1995. ‘Ever in process of becoming’: the autochthony of the Greeks, in The Good Idea, Democracy in Ancient Greece, ed. Koumoulides, J.A.. New Rochelle (NY): Caratzas, 7–28.Google Scholar
Renfrew, C., 1996. Who were the Minoans? Towards a population history of prehistoric Crete. Cretan Studies 5, 1–27.Google Scholar
Renfrew, C., in press. The loom of language and the Versailles effect, in Studies in the Aegean Bronze Age, ed. Laffineur, R.. (Aegaeum.) Liège: University of Liège.Google Scholar
Renfrew, C. & Aspinall, A., 1990. Aegean obsidian and the Franchthi Cave, in Les industries lithiques taillées de Franchthi (Argolide, Grèce), II, ed. Perlès, C.. Bloomington (IN): University of Indiana Press, 258–70.Google Scholar
Renfrew, J.M., 1973. Palacoethnobotany: the Prehistory of Food Plants of the Near East and Europe. London: Methuen.Google Scholar
Richards, M., Corte-Real, H., Forster, P., Macauley, V. et al. , 1996. Paleolithic and Neolithic lineages in the European mitochondrial gene pool. American Journal of Human Genetics 59, 185–203.Google ScholarPubMed
Ringe, D., in press. (Cited by Warnow, 1997.)Google Scholar
Risch, E., 1968. Dialectal classification of Mycenaean: conclusions, in Studia Mycenaea, ed. Bartonek, A.. Brno: Universita J.E. Purkyne, 207–10.Google Scholar
Risch, E. & Muhlstein, H. (eds.), 1979. Colloquium Mycenaeum. Neuchâtel: Université de Neuchâtel.Google Scholar
Roberts, H., 1981. Reconstructing the Greek tortoise-shell lyre. World Archaeology 12, 303–12.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rutter, J.B. & Zerner, C.W., 1984. Early Hellado-Minoan contacts, in Hägg, & Marinatos, (eds.), 75–83.Google Scholar
Sakellarakis, J. & Sakellarakis, E., 1991. Archanes. Athens: Ekdoteke Athenon.Google Scholar
Schachermeyr, F., 1954. Praehistorische Kulturen Griechenlands, in Paulys Real-Enzyklopädie der klassischen Altertumswissenschaft, Reihe 2, 22/2, ed. Stuttgart, G. Wissowa: Metzlersche, J.B., 1350–548.Google Scholar
Sherratt, E.S., 1992. Immigration and archaeology: some indirect reflections, in Acta Cypria, ed. Jonsered, P. Aström.: Forlag, Paul Aströms, 316–47.Google Scholar
Shevoroshkin, V.V., 1977. Zu einigen karischen Wörtern. Milnchener Studien zur Sprachwissenschaft 36, 117–30.Google Scholar
Starostin, S.A., 1991. On the hypothesis of a genetic connection between the Sino-Tibetan languages and the Yeniseian and North Caucasian languages, in Dene-Caucasian Languages, ed. Shevoroshkin, V.. Bochum: Brockmeyer, 12–41.Google Scholar
Sturtevant, F.H., 1962. The Indo-Hittite hypothesis. Language 38, 376–82.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Thimme, J., 1977. Art and Culture of the Cyclades. Karlsruhe: Muller.Google Scholar
van Andel, T.H. & Runnels, C.N., 1995. The earliest farmers in Europe. Antiquity 69, 481–500.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
van Effenterre, H., 1984. Le langage de la thalassocracie, in Hägg, & Marinatos, (eds.), 55–7.Google Scholar
M., Ventris & Chadwick, J., 1973. Documents in Mycenaean Greek. (2nd edition.) Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Vermeule, E., 1964. Greece in the Bronze Age. Chicago (IL): University of Chicago Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
T., Warnow, 1997. Mathematical approaches to comparative linguistics. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the USA 94(13), 6585–90.Google Scholar
Warren, P.M., 1973. Crete 3000–1400 Bc: immigration and archaeological evidence, in Crossland, & Birchall, (eds.), 41–50.Google Scholar
Watrous, L.V., 1994. Crete from earliest prehistory through the Protopalatial period. American Journal of Archaeology 98, 695–753.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wegner, M., 1949. Das Musiklcben der Griechen. Berlin: deGruyter.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wiener, M., 1984. Crete and the Cyclades in LMI: the tale of the conical cups, in Hagg, & Marinatos, (eds.), 17–25.Google Scholar
Wright, J.C., 1995. From chief to king in Mycenaean society, in Rehak, (ed.), 63–80.Google Scholar
Zvelebil, M., 1995. Indo-European origins and the agricultural transition in Europe. Journal of European Archaeology 3(1), 33–70.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Zvelebil, M. & Zvelebil, K.V., 1990. Agricultural transition, ‘Indo-European origins’, and the spread of farming, in Markey, & Greppin, (eds.), 237–66.Google Scholar