Religious Studies

The necessity of the present and Anselm's eternalist response to the problem of theological fatalism

a1 Philosophy Department, University of Delaware, Newark, DE 19716

Article author query
rogers ka   [Google Scholar] 


It is often argued that the eternalist solution to the freedom/foreknowledge dilemma fails. If God's knowledge of your choices is eternally fixed, your choices are necessary and cannot be free. Anselm of Canterbury proposes an eternalist view which entails that all of time is equally real and truly present to God. God's knowledge of your choices entails only a ‘consequent’ necessity which does not conflict with libertarian freedom. I argue this by showing that if consequent necessity does conflict with libertarian freedom then God's knowledge in the present would conflict with the freedom of a present choice. Absurd.

(Published Online January 15 2007)