No CrossRef data available.
Article contents
AGENCY AND THE “STAR WAR” GLYPH: A historical reassessment of Classic Maya astrology and warfare
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 28 March 2006
Abstract
Several studies over the past 20 years have argued for an explicit connection between a hieroglyphic record of war, the so-called star war, and the observation of Venus. To the last, these studies have relied on statistical treatments or simple numerical coincidence to substantiate their claims. In this paper I challenge the results of these studies on two levels. First, I demonstrate that the iconographic evidence that inspired the association between Venus and the “star war” verb is itself unstable; then I appeal to the historical contexts of the rulers engaged in this warfare to see if, as individuals, there is evidence that they held such a belief. In both cases, I show that the evidence does not support a ritual timing of Classic Maya warfare by the phases of Venus. At end, I turn to philological consideration to propose a new reading for the “star war” verb.
- Type
- Research Article
- Information
- Copyright
- © 2005 Cambridge University Press
References
REFERENCES
Aldana, Gerardo
2001a
Oracular Science: Uncertainty in the History of Maya
Astronomy.
Ph.D. dissertation,
History of Science, Harvard University,
Cambridge, MA.Google Scholar
Aldana, Gerardo
2001b
K'in in the Hieroglyphic Record: Implications of a
Pattern of Dates at Copán, Honduras.
Mesoweb; available at: www.mesoweb.com/aldana/implications.html.Google Scholar
Aldana, Gerardo
2002
Solar Stelae and a Venus Window: Science and Royal Personality in
Late Classic Copán.
Archaeoastronomy
27:S30–S50.Google Scholar
Aldana, Gerardo
2003
K'uk'ulkan at Mayapan: Venus and Postclassic Maya
Statecraft.
Journal for the History of Astronomy
34:33–51.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Aveni, Anthony F.
1980
Skywatchers of Ancient Mexico.
University of Texas Press,
Austin.Google Scholar
Aveni, Anthony F.
1981
Horizon Astronomy in Incaic Cuzco. In
Archaeoastronomy in the Americas, edited by
Ray Williamson, pp.
305–318.
Ballena,
Los Altos, CA.Google Scholar
Aveni, Anthony F.
1986
Introduction: Whither Archaeoastronomy? In
World Archaeoastronomy: Selected Papers from the Second Oxford
International Conference on Archaeoastronomy, 1986, edited by
Anthony F. Aveni, pp.
3–12.
Cambridge University Press,
New York.Google Scholar
Aveni, Anthony F.
1992
Introduction: Making Time. In
The Sky in Maya Literature, edited by
Anthony F. Aveni, pp.
16–17.
Oxford University Press,
Oxford.Google Scholar
Aveni, Anthony F., and
Lorren Hotaling
1994
Monumental Inscriptions and the Observational Basis of Maya
Planetary Astronomy.
Archaeoastronomy
19:S21–S54.Google Scholar
Barrera Vásquez, Alfredo
(director)
1995
Diccionario Maya.
Editorial Porrúa,
Mexico City.Google Scholar
Bielenstein, Hans
1950
An Interpretation of the Portents in the Ts'ien-Han Shu.
Bulletin of the Museum of Far Eastern Antiquities
22:127–143.Google Scholar
Bielenstein, Hans
1984
Han Portents and Prognostications.
Museum of Far Eastern Antiquities Bulletin
56:97–112.Google Scholar
Closs, Michael
1978
Venus in the Maya World: Glyphs, Gods and Associated Astronomical
Phenomena. In
Tercera Mesa Redonda de Palenque, Vol. IV, edited by
Merle Greene Robertson, pp.
158–163.
Pre-Columbian Art Research Center,
Palenque.Google Scholar
Closs, Michael
1981
Venus Dates Revisited.
Archaeoastronomy: The Bulletin of the Center for
Archaeoastronomy
4(4):38–41.Google Scholar
Closs, Michael
1994
A Glyph for Venus as Evening Star. In
Seventh Palenque Round Table, 1989, edited by
Merle Greene Robertson, pp.
229–236.
Pre-Columbian Art Research Institute,
San Francisco.Google Scholar
Closs, Michael,
Anthony F. Aveni, and
Bruce Crowley
1984
The Planet Venus and Temple 22 at Copán.
Indiana
9:221–247.Google Scholar
Dütting, Dieter, and
Mathias Schramm
1985
On the Astronomical Background of Mayan Historical Events.
In
Fifth Palenque Round Table, 1983, edited by
Virginia M. Fields, pp.
261–274.
Pre-Columbian Art Research Institute,
San Francisco.Google Scholar
Fox, James A., and
John S. Justeson
1984
Polyvalence in Mayan Hieroglyphic Writing. In
Phoneticism in Mayan Hieroglyphic Writing, edited by
John S. Justeson and
Lyle Campbell, pp.
17–76.
Institute for Mesoamerican Studies, Publication 9.
State University of New York,
Albany.Google Scholar
Freidel, David,
Linda Schele, and
Joy Parker
1993
Maya Cosmos.
William Morrow,
New York.Google Scholar
Grube, Nikolai
1996
Palenque in the Maya World. In
Eighth Palenque Round Table, 1993, edited by
Merle Greene Robertson, pp.
1–13.
Pre-Columbian Art Research Institute,
San Francisco.Google Scholar
Grube, Nikolai
2000
Fire Rituals in the Context of Classic Maya Initial Series. In The
Sacred and the Profane: Architecture and Identity in the Maya
Lowlands, pp.
93–109.
Acta Mesoamericana
10.Google Scholar
Hotaling, Lorren
1995
A Reply to Werner Nahm: Maya Warfare and the Venus Year.
Mexicon
17:32–37.Google Scholar
Houston, Stephen
1993
Hieroglyphs and History at Dos Pilas: Dynastic Politics of the
Classic Maya.
University of Texas Press,
Austin.Google Scholar
Houston, Stephen, and
David Stuart
1996
Of Gods, Glyphs, and Kings: Divinity and Rulership among the Classic
Maya.
Antiquity
70:289–312.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Houston, Stephen, and
David Stuart
1998
The Ancient Maya Self: Personhood and Portraiture in the Classic
Period.
Res
33:73–101.Google Scholar
Justeson, John S.
1989
Ancient Maya Ethnoastronomy: An Overview of Hieroglyphic
Sources. In
World Archaeoastronomy: Selected Papers from the Second Oxford
International Conference on Archaeoastronomy, 1986, edited by
Anthony F. Aveni, pp.
76–129.
Cambridge University Press,
New York.Google Scholar
Kelley, David
1977
Maya Astronomical Tables and Inscriptions. In
Native American Astronomy, edited by
Anthony F. Aveni, pp.
57–74.
University of Texas Press,
Austin.Google Scholar
Kelley, David
1980
Astronomical Identities of Mesoamerican Gods.
Archaeoastronomy
11(2):1–54.Google Scholar
Kelley, David
1983
Maya Calendar Correlation Problem. In
Civilization in the Ancient Americas, edited by
Richard M. Leventhal and
Alan L. Kolata, pp.
157–208.
University of New Mexico Press,
Albuquerque.Google Scholar
Lounsbury, Floyd
1978
Maya Numeration, Computation, and Calendrical Astronomy. In
Dictionary of Scientific Biography,
vol. 15, edited by
Charles Coulson Gillispie, pp.
759–818.
Charles Scribner's Sons,
New York.Google Scholar
Lounsbury, Floyd
1982
Astronomical Knowledge and Its Uses at Bonampak,
México. In
Archaeoastronomy in the New World, edited by
Anthony F. Aveni, pp.
143–169.
Cambridge University Press,
Cambridge.Google Scholar
Martin, Simon
1996
Tikal's “Star War” against Naranjo. In
Eighth Palenque Round Table, 1993, edited by
Martha J. Macri and
Jan McHargue, pp.
223–236.
Pre-Columbian Art Research Institute,
San Francisco.Google Scholar
Mathews, Peter, and
Gordon R. Willey
1991
Prehistoric Polities of the Pasion Region: Hieroglyphic Texts and
Their Archaeological Settings. In
Classic Maya Political History: Hieroglyphic and Archaeological
Evidence, edited by
T. Patrick Culbert, pp.
30–71.
Cambridge University Press,
Cambridge.Google Scholar
Sahagún, Bernardino de
1953
Florentine Codex: General History of the Things of New Spain. Book
7: The Sun, Moon, and Stars, and the Binding of the Years.
School of American Research, Archaeological Institute of America
Monograph 14, Part 8, Book 7.
University of Utah Press,
Ogden.Google Scholar
Sandstrom, Alan
1991
Corn Is Our Blood: Culture and Ethnic Identity in a Contemporary
Aztec Indian Village.
University of Oklahoma Press,
Norman.Google Scholar
Schele, Linda
1990
Lounsbury's Contrived Numbers and Two 8 Eb Dates at
Copán.
Copán Notes 81.
Copan Mosaics Project, Institute Hondureño de Antropologia e
Historia,
Austin.Google Scholar
Schele, Linda, and
David Freidel
1990
A Forest of Kings: The Untold Story of the Ancient Maya.
William Morrow,
New York.Google Scholar
Schele, Linda, and
Nikolai Grube
1994
Notebook for the XVIII Maya Hieroglyphic Workshop at Texas:
Tlaloc-Venus Warfare: The Peten Wars 8.17.0.0.0–9.15.13.0.0.
Institute of Latin American Studies,
University of Texas, Austin.Google Scholar
Schele, Linda, and
Nikolai Grube
1995
Notebook for the XIX Maya Hieroglyphic Workshop at Texas: The Last
Two Hundred Years of Classic Maya History: Transmission, Termination,
Transformation Post 9.15.0.0.0.
Institute of Latin American Studies,
University of Texas, Austin.Google Scholar
Schele, Linda, and
Nikolai Grube
1997
Notebook for the XXI Maya Hieroglyphic Workshop: The Dresden
Codex.
Institute of Latin American Studies,
University of Texas, Austin.Google Scholar
Schele, Linda, and
Peter Mathews
1998
The Code of Kings: The Language of Seven Sacred Maya Temples and
Tombs.
Simon and Schuster,
New York.Google Scholar
Schele, Linda, and
Mary Miller
1986
Blood of Kings: Dynasty and Ritual in Maya Art.
George Braziller,
NY, in association with the Kimball Art Museum, New York.Google Scholar
Siméon, Rémi
1977
Diccionario de la lengua Náhuatl o mexicana.
Siglo Veintiuno,
Mexico City.Google Scholar
Stuart, David S.
1995
A Study of Maya Inscriptions.
Ph.D. Dissertation,
Vanderbilt University,
Nashville, TN.Google Scholar
Stuart, David,
Stephen Houston, and
John Robertson
1999
Notebook for the XXIIIrd Maya Hieroglyphic Forum at Texas.
Maya Workshop Foundation,
University of Texas Press,
Austin.Google Scholar
Tate, Carolyn E.
1992
Yaxchilan: The Design of a Maya Ceremonial City.
University of Texas Press,
Austin.Google Scholar
Tedlock, Barbara
1992
The Road of Light. In
The Sky in Maya Literature, edited by
Anthony F. Aveni, pp.
18–42.
Oxford University Press,
Oxford.Google Scholar
Tedlock, Dennis
1992
Myth, Math, and Correlation in Mayan Books. In
The Sky in Maya Literature, edited by
Anthony F. Aveni.
Oxford University Press,
New York.Google Scholar
Teeple, John
1930
Maya Astronomy.
Carnegie Institution of Washington Publication 103.
Carnegie Institution of Washington,
Washington, DC.Google Scholar
Thompson, J. Eric
1971
Maya Hieroglyphic Writing: An Introduction.
University of Oklahoma Press,
Norman.Google Scholar
Thompson, J. Eric
1972
A Commentary on the Dresden Codex.
Memoirs, vol. 93.
American Philosophical Society,
Philadelphia.Google Scholar
Velásquez, Primo Feliciano
(translator)
1975
Codice Chimalpopoca: Anales de Cuauhtitlan y Leyenda de los
Soles.
Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México,
Mexico City.Google Scholar
Wisdom, Charles
1950
Chorti–English Dictionary (1950).
Transcribed and transliterated by Brian Stross.
University of Texas,
Austin.Google Scholar